Input: "31" "." "Kassaator" "," "Itaalia" "ja" "Austria" "valitsused" "ning" "Euroopa" "Komisjon" "on" "esitanud" "oma" "kirjalikud" "seisukohad" "."


Input: "Kõik" "nimetatud" "menetlusosalised" "peale" "Itaalia" "valitsuse" "esitasid" "29" "." "mail" "2018" "peetud" "kohtuistungil" "ka" "oma" "suulised" "seisukohad" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "IV" "." "Hinnang"


Input: "32" "." "Kas" "uuele" "õigusnormile" "tuginedes" "saab" "vaidlustada" "jätkuvad" "tagajärjed" "," "mis" "on" "põhjustatud" "haldusotsusest" "," "mis" "tehti" "ja" "muutus" "lõplikuks" "enne" "selle" "uue" "õigusnormi" "jõustumist" "?"


Input: "See" "on" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "esimese" "küsimuse" "peamine" "sisu" "."


Input: "33" "." "Sellistel" "asjaoludel" "nagu" "põhikohtuasjas" "olen" "seisukohal" "," "et" "vastus" "on" "eitav" "."


Input: "34" "." "Kui" "arvestada" "," "et" "teen" "ettepaneku" "vastata" "esimesele" "küsimusele" "eitavalt" "(" "A" "osa" ")" "," "ei" "ole" "ülejäänud" "küsimustele" "vaja" "vastata" "."


Input: "Juhuks" "," "kui" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "jõuab" "teistsugusele" "järeldusele" "," "käsitlen" "põgusalt" "ka" "neid" "küsimusi" "(" "B" "ja" "C" "osad" ")" "," "aga" "ka" "ELTL" "artikli" "157" "(" "varem" "EÜ" "artikkel" "141" ")" "olulisust" "käesolevas" "asjas" "."


Input: "Eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "ei" "ole" "viimati" "nimetatud" "sätet" "oma" "küsimustes" "maininud" "," "kuid" "sellele" "on" "osutanud" "kassaator" "(" "D" "osa" ")" "."


Input: "A" "." "Esimene" "küsimus"


Input: "35" "." "Kas" "juhul" "," "kui" "haldusotsus" "," "millega" "kaasnes" "diskrimineerimine" "seksuaalse" "sättumuse" "alusel" "ja" "pensioni" "vähendamine" "," "muutus" "lõplikuks" "enne" "," "kui" "selline" "diskrimineerimine" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "kohaselt" "keelati" "," "on" "vähendatud" "pensioni" "jätkuvalt" "maksmine" "õigusvastane" "nüüd" "," "kui" "see" "direktiiv" "on" "jõus" "?"


Input: "See" "on" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "esimese" "küsimuse" "sisu" "."


Input: "36" "." "Eelotsusetaotluses" "on" "märgitud" "," "et" "esimene" "küsimus" "ei" "ole" "seotud" "kassaatori" "pensionile" "saatmise" "ja" "tema" "pensioni" "vähendamise" "otsuse" "õiguspärasusega" "."


Input: "See" "vaidlustati" "1970" "." "aastatel" "ja" "kassaator" "proovis" "seda" "(" "edutult" ")" "uuesti" "vaidlustada" "pärast" "seda" "," "kui" "õigusi" "riivav" "karistusõigusnorm" "kehtetuks" "tunnistati" "."


Input: "37" "." "Eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "soovib" "–" "kuivõrd" "kõnealuse" "haldusotsusega" "kaasnes" "diskrimineerimine" "–" "teada" "hoopis" "seda" "," "kas" "direktiiviga" "2000" "/" "78" "on" "vastuolus" "selle" "otsuse" "tagajärgede" "säilitaminevähendatud" "pensioni" "jätkumise" "osas" "."


Input: "38" "." "Seda" "küsimust" "käsitledes" "viitan" "kõigepealt" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "üldisele" "lähenemisviisile" "seoses" "uute" "õigusnormide" "ajalise" "kohaldamisega" "varem" "eksisteerinud" "olukordade" "jätkuvatele" "tagajärgedele" "(" "1" "." "jagu" ")" "."


Input: "Seejärel" "asun" "käsitlema" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "lähenemisviisi" "konkreetselt" "pensioni" "puudutanud" "kohtuasjades" "(" "2" "." "jagu" ")" "."


Input: "Järgmiseks" "tutvustan" "kohtupraktikat" "jätkuvate" "suhete" "kohta" "(" "3" "." "jagu" ")" "ning" "varasemate" "otsuste" "uuesti" "läbivaatamise" "kohustuse" "ulatuse" "kohta" "(" "4" "." "jagu" ")" "."


Input: "Lõpuks" "kohaldan" "tehtud" "järeldusi" "käesolevale" "asjale" "(" "5" "." "jagu" ")" "."


Input: "39" "." "Enne" "nende" "küsimuste" "juurde" "asumist" "on" "aga" "vaja" "kahte" "sissejuhatavat" "märkust" "."


Input: "40" "." "Esiteks" "näivad" "menetlusosalised" "olevat" "nõus" "," "et" "see" "," "kuidas" "Austria" "karistusõiguses" "käsitleti" "1974" "." "aastal" "seksuaalsuhteid" "alaealistega" "olenevalt" "sellest" "," "kas" "need" "suhted" "olid" "homo" "‑" "või" "heteroseksuaalsed" "," "ei" "oleks" "tänapäeval" "enam" "aktsepteeritav" "."


Input: "Loogiliselt" "peaks" "seesama" "paika" "pidama" "ka" "seoses" "distsiplinaarotsuses" "sisaldunud" "viidetega" "kassaatori" "seksuaalsusele" "."


Input: "Õigupoolest" "ei" "vaidlustanud" "Austria" "valitsus" "ühtegi" "nendest" "seisukohaväljendustest" "."


Input: "Sellegipoolest" "–" "ja" "ilma" "," "et" "talle" "oleks" "seepeale" "vastu" "vaieldud" "–" "märkis" "Austria" "valitsus" "," "et" "kõnealused" "kriminaal" "‑" "ja" "distsiplinaarkaristused" "olid" "1974" "." "ja" "1975" "." "aastal" "Austria" "õiguses" "täiesti" "seaduslikud" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Samuti" "avaldas" "Austria" "valitsus" "arvamust" "," "et" "need" "olid" "kooskõlas" "tollal" "kehtinud" "Euroopa" "normidega" "," "mis" "on" "sestpeale" "edasi" "arenenud" "."


Input: "41" "." "Teiseks" "on" "käesoleva" "asja" "kontekstis" "palju" "vähem" "selge" "," "milline" "täpselt" "on" "põhikohtuasjas" "suhe" "kriminaal" "‑" "ja" "distsiplinaarkaristuste" "vahel" "."


Input: "Eelkõige" "käsitleti" "nii" "kirjalikes" "seisukohtades" "kui" "ka" "kohtuistungil" "üsna" "ulatuslikult" "küsimust" "," "kas" "(" "teatava" "rangusastmega" ")" "distsiplinaarkaristus" "oli" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdimõistmise" "vajalik" "tagajärg" "."


Input: "Ühest" "küljest" "ei" "eristatud" "ametnike" "suhtes" "kohaldatavates" "(" "üsna" "üldiselt" "sõnastatud" "(" "5" ")" ")" "distsiplinaareeskirjades" "erinevalt" "karistusseadustikust" "käitumist" "olenevalt" "sellest" "," "kas" "see" "oli" "homo" "‑" "või" "heteroseksuaalset" "laadi" "."


Input: "Teisest" "küljest" "on" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "eelotsusetaotluses" "märkinud" "," "et" "kui" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdimõistmist" "ei" "oleks" "olnud" "," "oleks" "rakendatav" "distsiplinaarkaristus" "olnud" "„" "märkimisväärselt" "leebem" "“" "."


Input: "42" "." "Vastuseks" "küsimustele" "kriminaal" "‑" "ja" "distsiplinaarkaristuste" "vahelise" "täpse" "suhte" "kohta" "märkis" "Austria" "valitsus" "," "et" "1974" "." "aastal" "ei" "olnud" "politseiametniku" "suhtes" "jõustunud" "kriminaalkaristus" "piisav" "tema" "automaatseks" "töölt" "vallandamiseks" "." "(" "6" ")" "Selline" "süüdimõistmine" "ei" "olnud" "aga" "ka" "distsiplinaarkaristuse" "määramiseks" "vajalik" "."


Input: "Aastal" "1974" "olid" "Austria" "politseiametnikud" "kohustatud" "nii" "teenistuses" "kui" "ka" "väljaspool" "teenistust" "eeskujulikult" "käituma" "."


Input: "Nii" "ei" "tähendanud" "see" "," "kui" "teatavas" "käitumises" "ei" "saanud" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdi" "mõista" "(" "või" "ei" "olnud" "see" "käitumine" "üldse" "kriminaliseeritud" ")" "," "seda" "," "et" "see" "ei" "kujutanud" "endast" "probleemi" "distsiplinaareeskirjade" "seisukohast" "."


Input: "Selle" "kohta" "märkis" "Austria" "valitsus" "," "ilma" "et" "talle" "oleks" "seepeale" "vastu" "vaieldud" "," "et" "tõenäoliselt" "ei" "oleks" "seda" "," "kui" "32aastane" "politseiametnik" "avalikus" "pargis" "14" "‑" "ja" "15aastast" "isikut" "ahvatleb" "," "olenemata" "seksuaalsest" "sättumusest" "eeskujulikuks" "käitumiseks" "peetud" "."


Input: "Eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "on" "ju" "kinnitanud" "," "et" "samaväärset" "alaealiste" "heteroseksuaalset" "ahvatlemist" "avalikus" "pargis" "oleks" "saanud" "käsitada" "ametikohustuste" "täitmata" "jätmisega" "," "mis" "oli" "tollal" "distsiplinaarkorras" "karistatav" "."


Input: "43" "." "Teen" "nendest" "seisukohaväljendustest" "kahetise" "järelduse" "."


Input: "Esiteks" "mõistan" "," "et" "ainuüksi" "selles" "asjaolus" "," "et" "politseiametnik" "oli" "kriminaalkorras" "lõplikult" "süüdi" "mõistetud" "," "tuli" "enesestmõistetavalt" "näha" "tema" "ametikohustuste" "täitmata" "jätmist" "."


Input: "On" "üsna" "selge" "," "et" "politseiametnikelt" "eeldatakse" "käitumist" "kõrgemal" "tasemel" "kui" "pelgalt" "„" "kuritegude" "toime" "panemata" "jätmine" "“" "."


Input: "Selles" "mõttes" "on" "niisiis" "täiesti" "loogiline" "," "et" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdimõistmine" "põhjustas" "endastmõistetavalt" "otseseid" "tagajärgi" "võimalike" "karistuste" "skaala" "suhtes" "," "muutes" "need" "„" "märkimisväärselt" "rangemaks" "“" "kui" "juhtudel" "," "mil" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdimõistmist" "ei" "olnud" "." "(" "7" ")" "Teiseks" "mõistan" "samuti" "," "et" "peale" "selle" "ühepoolse" "(" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdimõistmisest" "distsiplinaarkorras" "süüdimõistmiseni" ")" "karistuse" "rangusega" "seotud" "tagajärje" "ei" "olnud" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdimõistmine" "distsiplinaarkaristuse" "määramiseks" "vajalik" "eeltingimus" "."


Input: "1" "." "Uute" "õigusnormide" "ajaline" "kohaldatavus"


Input: "a" ")" "Üldine" "lähenemisviis"


Input: "44" "." "Euroopa" "Kohtus" "välja" "kujunenud" "praktika" "kohaselt" "kohaldatakse" "uut" "normi" "„" "varasema" "normi" "kehtivusajal" "tekkinud" "olukorra" "tulevastele" "tagajärgedele" "“" "kohe" "ja" "õiguspärase" "ootuse" "põhimõtte" "kohaldamisala" "ei" "saa" "laiendada" "selleni" "," "et" "„" "see" "hakkab" "üldiselt" "takistama" "uue" "normi" "kohaldamist" "varasema" "normi" "kehtivusajal" "tekkinud" "olukordade" "tulevaste" "tagajärgede" "suhtes" "“" "." "(" "8" ")"


Input: "45" "." "Selleks" "aga" "," "et" "tagada" "õiguskindluse" "põhimõtte" "ja" "õiguspärase" "ootuse" "kaitse" "põhimõtte" "järgimine" "," "tuleb" "liidu" "materiaalõigusnorme" "tõlgendada" "nii" "," "et" "„" "need" "on" "enne" "nende" "jõustumist" "tekkinud" "olukordade" "“" "suhtes" "kohaldatavad" "üksnes" "siis" "," "kui" "„" "selline" "võimalus" "nähtub" "selgelt" "nende" "sõnastusest" "," "eesmärgist" "või" "ülesehitusest" "“" "." "(" "9" ")"


Input: "46" "." "Teise" "vormeli" "kohaselt" "," "mida" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "on" "kasutanud" "," "„" "ei" "kohaldata" "[" "uut" "õigusnormi" "]" "varasema" "õigusakti" "kehtivusajal" "tekkinud" "ja" "lõplikult" "väljakujunenud" "õiguslikele" "olukordadele" "," "[" "kuid" "uut" "õigusnormi" "]" "kohaldatakse" "nende" "olukordade" "tulevikus" "tekkivate" "tagajärgede" "suhtes" "ja" "ka" "uute" "õiguslike" "olukordade" "suhtes" "."


Input: "Teisiti" "on" "üksnes" "siis" "," "kui" "uue" "õigusnormiga" "kaasnevad" "erisätted" "," "mis" "määravad" "konkreetselt" "kindlaks" "selle" "ajalise" "kohaldamise" "tingimused" "," "kui" "õigusaktide" "tagasiulatuva" "jõu" "puudumise" "põhimõttest" "ei" "tulene" "teisiti" "“" "." "(" "10" ")"


Input: "47" "." "Niisiis" "saab" "nendest" "kohtuasjadest" "tulenenud" "üldreegleid" "kirjeldada" "järgmiselt" ":" "1" ")" "uute" "õigusnormide" "kohaldamata" "jätmine" "„" "lõplikult" "välja" "kujunenud" "olukordade" "“" "suhtes" "," "mis" "tekkisid" "ja" "mille" "suhtes" "tehti" "otsus" "vanade" "õigusnormide" "kehtivusajal" "," "ja" "2" ")" "uute" "õigusnormide" "kohaldamine" "jätkuvaid" "tagajärgi" "tekitavate" "„" "olemasolevate" "olukordade" "“" "tulevikus" "tekkivate" "tagajärgede" "suhtes" "."


Input: "Varasemaid" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "võetakse" "uute" "õigusnormide" "kohaselt" "uue" "õigusliku" "hinnangu" "andmiseks" "arvesse" "vaid" "siis" "," "kui" "selle" "hinnangu" "andmine" "on" "uute" "õigusnormide" "olemusest" "või" "ülesehitusest" "tulenevalt" "ette" "nähtud" "või" "vajalik" "."


Input: "48" "." "Sama" "lähenemisviis" "kajastub" "ka" "uue" "liikmesriigi" "Euroopa" "Liiduga" "ühinemise" "kontekstis" "(" "11" ")" "nii" "seoses" "(" "uute" ")" "liidu" "õigusnormide" "riigisisese" "kohaldamisega" "kui" "ka" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "pädevusega" "teha" "eelotsuseid" "selliste" "olukordadega" "seotud" "küsimustele" "vastamiseks" "."


Input: "Minevikus" "tekkinud" "(" "s.o" "ühinemisele" "eelnenud" ")" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "võib" "arvesse" "võtta" "," "kui" "need" "on" "asjakohased" "ja" "neid" "on" "vaja" "pärast" "ühinemist" "uu" "(" "t" ")" "e" "seadus" "(" "t" ")" "e" "kohaldamisel" "(" "uuesti" ")" "hinnata" "." "(" "12" ")" "Nii" "näiteks" "ei" "olnud" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "pädev" "andma" "ühinemise" "järel" "materiaalõiguslikult" "uut" "hinnangut" "küsimuses" "," "kas" "mõningad" "tingimused" "enne" "ühinemist" "sõlmitud" "tarbijalepingus" "olid" "ebaõiglased" "," "isegi" "kui" "tegelikult" "toimub" "selle" "lepingu" "täitmine" "pärast" "ühinemist" "." "(" "13" ")" "Seevastu" "oli" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "pädev" "hindama" "," "kas" "liidu" "õigusega" "on" "kooskõlas" "riigisisesed" "õigusaktid" "," "millega" "seati" "ülempiir" "enne" "ühinemist" "sõlmitud" "seadusliku" "tehinguga" "seotud" "viivistele" "ja" "mille" "tagajärjed" "(" "ja" "nende" "lõplik" "väljaarvutamine" ")" "jätkusid" "ka" "pärast" "ühinemist" "." "(" "14" ")"


Input: "b" ")" "Kohtuotsus" "Ciola"

"O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS"
"O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT"
"O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION"
"O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT"
"O" "O" "O" "B-TIME"
"O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS"
"O" "O" "O" "B-DATE"
"O" "O" "O" "I-TIME"
"O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION"
"O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON"
"O" "O" "O" "I-DATE"
"O" "O" "O" "B-PERSON"


Input: "49" "." "Nii" "kassaator" "kui" "ka" "komisjon" "on" "oma" "kirjalikes" "ja" "suulistes" "seisukohtades" "ulatuslikult" "tuginenud" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "otsusele" "Ciola" "." "(" "15" ")" "Seda" "otsust" "tuleb" "tõesti" "üksikasjalikult" "vaadata" "," "sest" "see" "näitab" "," "kuidas" "eelmises" "jaos" "tutvustatud" "üldsuuniseid" "kohaldatakse" "konkreetse" "juhtumi" "kontekstis" "."


Input: "50" "." "Kohtuasjas" "Ciola" "oli" "nii-öelda" "maagiline" "kuupäev" "1" "." "jaanuar" "1995" "," "mil" "Austria" "Euroopa" "ühendustega" "ühines" "."

"O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Sel" "kuupäeval" "jõustus" "selles" "uues" "liikmesriigis" "täielikult" "–" "mõistagi" "peale" "sõnaselgete" "erandite" "–" "ja" "muutus" "kohe" "kohaldatavaks" "ühenduse" "õigus" "," "sealhulgas" "vaba" "liikumist" "käsitlevad" "õigusnormid" "."


Input: "51" "." "E" "." "Ciola" "äriühing" "omas" "ja" "andis" "üürile" "200" "kaikohta" "lõbusõidupaatidele" "Bodeni" "järve" "Austriale" "kuuluvas" "osas" "."

"O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Aastal" "1990" "tehtud" "haldusotsuse" "kohaselt" "tohtis" "välismaalastele" "üürile" "anda" "maksimaalselt" "60" "kaikohta" "." "(" "16" ")" "Igal" "aastal" "tuli" "esitada" "välismaalastele" "antud" "kaikohtade" "loetelu" "." "(" "17" ")"


Input: "52" "." "10" "." "juulil" "1996" "(" "18" "kuud" "pärast" "liiduga" "ühinemist" ")" "tehti" "uus" "haldusotsus" "," "milles" "tunnistati" "äriühing" "süüdi" "selles" "," "et" "ta" "andis" "jaanuaris" "ja" "mais" "1995" "välismaalastele" "üürile" "kaks" "kaikohta" "," "mis" "ületasid" "ettenähtud" "60" "kaikoha" "suurust" "ülempiiri" "."

"O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "E" "." "Ciolale" "mõisteti" "1990" "." "aasta" "haldusotsuse" "rikkumise" "kummagi" "juhu" "eest" "trahv" "." "(" "18" ")" "Ta" "esitas" "1996" "." "aasta" "trahvi" "määramise" "otsuse" "peale" "kaebuse" "."

"B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Selles" "kohtuasjas" "taotleti" "eelotsust" "Euroopa" "Kohtult" "," "kusjuures" "teises" "eelotsuse" "küsimuses" "soovis" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "sõnaselgelt" "teada" "piirangu" "ajalise" "kohaldamise" "ulatuse" "kohta" "," "kuna" "algne" "haldusotsus" "muutus" "lõplikuks" "enne" "liiduga" "ühinemist" "."


Input: "53" "." "Euroopa" "Kohus" "alustas" "oma" "põhjendusi" "kinnitusest" "," "et" "kaikohtade" "arvu" "piiramine" "välismaalastele" "on" "teenuste" "vaba" "liikumise" "normide" "kohaselt" "keelatud" "."


Input: "Ta" "lisas" "siiski" "," "et" "„" "vaidlus" "puudutab" "mitte" "haldusakti" "enda" "–" "käesoleval" "juhul" "9" "." "augusti" "1990" "." "aasta" "otsuse" "–" "saatust" "," "vaid" "küsimust" "," "kas" "selline" "akt" "tuleb" "jätta" "arvesse" "võtmata" "hinnangu" "andmisel" "niisuguse" "karistuse" "õiguspärasuse" "kohta" "," "mis" "on" "määratud" "[" "pärast" "liiduga" "ühinemise" "kuupäeva" "]" "sellest" "aktist" "tuleneva" "kohustuse" "täitmata" "jätmise" "eest" "," "kuna" "see" "kohustus" "ei" "ole" "kooskõlas" "teenuste" "osutamise" "vabaduse" "põhimõttega" "“" "." "(" "19" ")" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "järeldas" "," "et" "niisugune" "akt" "tuleb" "jätta" "arvesse" "võtmata" "."


Input: "54" "." "Käesoleval" "juhul" "viitab" "kassaator" "kohtuotsusele" "Ciola" "nii" "," "nagu" "oleks" "seal" "sisuliselt" "märgitud" "," "et" "haldusotsuse" "ebasoodsate" "tagajärgede" "all" "kannataval" "isikul" "on" "õigus" "nende" "tagajärgede" "nullimisele" "," "kui" "hüpoteetiliselt" "oleks" "see" "haldusotsus" "olnud" "nende" "õigusnormidega" "vastuolus" "siis" "," "kui" "see" "oleks" "vastu" "võetud" "pärast" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "."


Input: "55" "." "Niisugust" "järeldust" "kohtuotsusest" "Ciola" "siiski" "ei" "tulene" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Kohtuasjas" "Ciola" "vaidlustas" "kaebaja" "pärast" "vaba" "liikumise" "normide" "Austrias" "jõustumise" "kuupäeva" "määratud" "trahvi" "õiguspärasuse" "."

"O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Peale" "selle" "oli" "kõnealune" "trahv" "määratud" "E" "." "Ciola" "äriühingu" "tegevuse" "–" "jaanuaris" "ja" "mais" "1995" "kaikohtade" "rentimise" "–" "eest" "," "mis" "ise" "oli" "toimunud" "pärast" "liiduga" "ühinemise" "kuupäeva" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "56" "." "Seega" "on" "üsna" "selge" "," "et" "kohtuasjas" "Ciola" "kohaldati" "ühinemisjärgseid" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "," "mida" "oli" "loogiliselt" "vaja" "uuele" "olukorrale" "hinnangu" "andmiseks" "."


Input: "Ühinemisjärgseid" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "(" "kaikohtade" "üürile" "andmine" ")" "tuli" "hinnata" "ja" "võrrelda" "uute" "," "ühinemisjärgsete" "õigusnormidega" "(" "riigisiseste" "õigusnormidega" "," "mida" "tuli" "kohandada" "vastavaks" "liidu" "õigusnormidele" "," "mis" "olid" "kohaldatavaks" "muutunud" ")" "."


Input: "Samuti" "on" "selge" "," "et" "mingit" "1990" "." "aasta" "otsuse" "(" "minevikus" "tekkinud" ")" "tagajärgede" "„" "nullimist" "“" "selles" "mõttes" "," "mida" "kassaator" "silmas" "pidas" "," "ei" "olnud" "."


Input: "Euroopa" "Kohus" "ei" "märkinud" "," "et" "see" "otsus" "tuleb" "uuesti" "läbi" "vaadata" "või" "et" "selle" "otsuse" "varasema" "olemasolu" "eest" "tuleb" "maksta" "hüvitist" "."


Input: "Ta" "nõudis" "hoopis" "seda" "," "et" "vana" "otsust" "," "mis" "oli" "sattunud" "vastuollu" "uute" "," "1995" "." "aastale" "järgnenud" "õigusnormidega" "," "ei" "tohi" "pärast" "liiduga" "ühinemist" "seoses" "halduskaristuste" "rakendamisega" "enam" "õigusnormide" "uue" "ja" "ajakohastatud" "kohaldamise" "raames" "kohaldada" "."


Input: "2" "." "Konkreetne" "kohtupraktika" "pensionide" "kohta"


Input: "57" "." "Eelnevas" "jaos" "tutvustatud" "üldine" "lähenemisviis" "on" "kohaldatav" "ka" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ja" "pensioniskeemide" "kontekstis" "." "(" "20" ")" "See" "aga" "," "kuidas" "täpselt" "need" "õigusnormid" "ühel" "või" "teisel" "juhul" "kohalduvad" "," "ei" "ole" "enesestmõistetav" "."


Input: "Pensioniskeemide" "erisusi" "ei" "saa" "eirata" "."


Input: "Õigusi" "lisandub" "ja" "pensione" "makstakse" "välja" "aastakümneid" "," "mille" "kestel" "võivad" "seadused" "oluliselt" "muutuda" "."


Input: "Olukorra" "muudab" "delikaatsemaks" "see" "," "et" "pensionidega" "seotud" "vaidlused" "võivad" "puudutada" "üksikisiku" "ning" "kokkuvõttes" "ka" "riigi" "ja" "erapensionifondide" "jaoks" "suuri" "rahasummasid" "."


Input: "58" "." "See" "on" "tõepoolest" "oluline" "aspekt" "," "mis" "läbib" "kohtuotsuseid" "," "mida" "käsitletakse" "käesolevas" "jaos" "seoses" "pensionit" "puudutavate" "küsimustega" "."


Input: "Valdav" "enamik" "nendest" "kohtuasjadest" "olid" "seotud" "pensionialaste" "otsustega" "," "mis" "on" "tehtud" "pärast" "uute" "reeglite" "jõustumist" "."


Input: "a" ")" "Vanad" "faktilised" "asjaolud" "," "uued" "õigusnormid" "ja" "vajadus" "uue" "otsuse" "järele"


Input: "59" "." "Paljudes" "konkreetselt" "pensionidega" "seotud" "kohtuasjades" "on" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "kinnitanud" "," "et" "pensioni" "saamise" "õiguse" "kindlakstegemisel" "on" "vaja" "arvesse" "võtta" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "(" "eeskätt" "teenistusperioode" ")" "," "mis" "eelnesid" "uute" "," "diskrimineerimist" "keelustavate" "õigusnormide" "jõustumisele" "."


Input: "60" "." "Nii" "näiteks" "puudutasid" "kohtuasjad" "Bruno" "ja" "O" "’" "Brien" "(" "21" ")" "osalise" "tööajaga" "töötajate" "ja" "täistööajaga" "töötajate" "võrdset" "kohtlemist" "," "mis" "on" "ette" "nähtud" "direktiiviga" "97" "/" "81" "/" "EÜ" "." "(" "22" ")" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "otsustas" "nendes" "kohtuasjades" "," "et" "tuvastades" "," "kas" "isik" "kvalifitseerub" "pensioni" "saama" "," "tuleb" "arvesse" "võtta" "selle" "direktiivi" "jõustumisele" "eelnenud" "osalise" "tööajaga" "tööperioode" "." "(" "23" ")" "Mõlemas" "nimetatud" "kohtuasjas" "tuli" "pensioniõigus" "kindlaks" "teha" "pärast" "direktiivi" "jõustumist" "." "(" "24" ")"


Input: "61" "." "Samamoodi" "oli" "kohtuasjades" "Barber" "(" "25" ")" "ja" "Ten" "Oever" "(" "26" ")" "," "kus" "oli" "vaidluse" "all" "väidetav" "EÜ" "artikli" "119" "vastane" "sooline" "diskrimineerimine" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Nendes" "kohtuasjades" "tehti" "pensioniõigus" "kindlaks" "pärast" "EMÜ" "artikli" "119" "jõustumist" "." "(" "27" ")"


Input: "62" "." "Kohtuasjas" "Maruko" "(" "28" ")" "seisnes" "probleem" "toitjakaotuspensioni" "saamise" "õiguse" "andmata" "jätmises" "väidetavalt" "seksuaalse" "sättumuse" "alusel" "diskrimineerimise" "tõttu" "vastuolus" "direktiiviga" "2000" "/" "78" "."


Input: "Nagu" "oli" "olnud" "kohtuasjas" "Ten" "Oever" "," "(" "29" ")" "toimus" "asjasse" "puutuv" "sündmus" "ja" "tehti" "uus" "otsus" "(" "partneri" "surm" "ja" "otsus" "mitte" "määrata" "toitjakaotuspensioni" ")" "pärast" "õigusnormide" "liikmesriigi" "õigusse" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "möödumist" "." "(" "30" ")"


Input: "63" "." "Kohtuasjades" "Kauer" "ja" "Duchon" "oli" "sisuliselt" "kõne" "all" "kodakondsuse" "alusel" "diskrimineerimine" "." "(" "31" ")" "Nendes" "kohtuasjades" "olid" "kaebajad" "taotlenud" "pensioni" "Austrias" "pärast" "liiduga" "ühinemist" "ning" "palunud" "arvesse" "võtta" "teatavaid" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "," "mis" "olid" "tekkinud" "teises" "liikmesriigis" "enne" "," "kui" "Austria" "liiduga" "ühines" "(" "kohtuasjas" "Kauer" "lapseootel" "oleku" "perioodid" "Belgias" "ning" "kohtuasjas" "Duchon" "töövõimetuse" "põhjustanud" "tööõnnetusjuhtum" "Saksamaal" ")" "."

"O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"


Input: "64" "." "Kokkuvõttes" "puudutasid" "kõik" "eespool" "viidatud" "pensionialased" "kohtuasjad" "olukordi" "," "kus" "pärast" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "otsuse" "tegemisel" "võetakse" "arvesse" "enne" "nende" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "tekkinud" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "."


Input: "See" "on" "täielikus" "vastavuses" "eespool" "viidatud" "üldise" "kohtupraktikaga" ":" "esineb" "jätkuv" "faktiline" "olukord" "," "mille" "suhtes" "on" "vaja" "anda" "ajakohastatud" "õiguslik" "hinnang" "pärast" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "."


Input: "Niisugustes" "olukordades" "on" "täiesti" "loogiline" "," "eriti" "sotsiaalkindlustuse" "kontekstis" "," "et" "arvesse" "võetakse" "kõiki" "uutele" "õigusnormidele" "eelnenud" "olulisi" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "."


Input: "65" "." "Sel" "põhjusel" "ei" "ole" "nimetatud" "kohtupraktika" "minu" "arvates" "kohaldatav" "käesolevas" "asjas" "," "kus" "faktilised" "asjaolud" "," "kohaldatavad" "õigusnormid" "," "aga" "ka" "haldusotsus" "ise" "eelnesid" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumisele" "."


Input: "Ainsad" "uutele" "õigusnormidele" "järgnenud" "faktilised" "asjaolud" "on" "kassaatorile" "tehtud" "pensionimaksed" "."


Input: "66" "." "Olukord" "on" "seda" "enam" "nii" "," "et" "käesolevas" "asjas" "puudutab" "väidetav" "diskrimineeriv" "otsus" "hinnangu" "andmist" "ja" "õigusnormide" "kohaldamist" "niisuguste" "faktiliste" "asjaolude" "suhtes" "," "mis" "ei" "ole" "ise" "otseselt" "seotud" "pensioniõiguse" "ega" "pensionisumma" "arvutamisega" "."


Input: "Väidetav" "diskrimineerimine" "on" "seotud" "distsiplinaarotsusega" "," "millega" "on" "kassaatori" "süüd" "kinnitades" "määratud" "talle" "kaheosaline" "distsiplinaarkaristus" "." "(" "32" ")" "Mõistagi" "ei" "saa" "eitada" "," "et" "see" "otsus" "on" "põhjustanud" "tagasilööke" "kassaatori" "pensioni" "suhtes" "." "(" "33" ")" "Ent" "erinevalt" "käesolevas" "jaos" "käsitletud" "kohtuasjadest" "ei" "esine" "käesolevas" "kohtuasjas" "näiteks" "objektiivseid" "õigustavaid" "tingimusi" "," "mis" "puudutaksid" "isiklikke" "olukordi" "või" "teenistusperioode" "."


Input: "Käesolev" "kohtuasi" "puudutab" "hoopis" "eraldi" "distsiplinaarotsust" "," "mis" "oli" "seotud" "konkreetsete" "faktiliste" "asjaoludega" "."


Input: "b" ")" "Olemasolevad" "pensionid" "," "uued" "õigusnormid" "ja" "praegused" "olukorrad"


Input: "67" "." "Kohtuotsus" "Römer" "," "(" "34" ")" "millele" "on" "viidanud" "kõik" "menetlusosalised" "," "ei" "sobi" "eespool" "kirjeldatud" "mustriga" "kuigi" "hästi" "."


Input: "Sellepärast" "väärib" "see" "üksikasjalikumat" "käsitelu" "."


Input: "68" "." "Nimetatud" "kohtuasjas" "oli" "meessoost" "hageja" "tegelikult" "juba" "pensionil" "ja" "sai" "pensionimakseid" "," "kui" "ta" "registreeris" "2001" "." "aastal" "(" "s.o" "enne" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "lõppu" ")" "oma" "kooselu" "meessoost" "elukaaslasega" "."


Input: "J" "." "Römerile" "ei" "võimaldatud" "maksualast" "liigitust" "," "mida" "oleks" "üldjuhul" "kohaldatud" "(" "heteroseksuaalse" ")" "abielu" "korral" "(" "35" ")" "ja" "mis" "oleks" "andnud" "talle" "õiguse" "saada" "suuremaid" "pensionimakseid" "."

"I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "69" "." "Euroopa" "Kohus" "otsustas" "sisuliselt" "," "et" "niivõrd" "," "kui" "tegu" "on" "diskrimineerimisega" "," "võib" "J" "." "Römer" "nõuda" "maksustamisel" "võrdset" "kohtlemist" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "möödumisest" "alates" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Erinevalt" "teistest" "eespool" "viidatud" "kohtuasjadest" "aga" "tehti" "kohtuasjas" "Römer" "otsus" "hageja" "pensioniõiguse" "kohta" "enne" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "."


Input: "Küsimus" "oli" "jätkuvas" "diskrimineerimises" "," "mis" "puudutas" "edaspidiseid" "väljamakseid" "ja" "hageja" "olukorda" "maksustamisel" "."


Input: "70" "." "See" "kohtuasi" "aga" "erineb" "käesolevast" "," "ja" "seda" "eeskätt" "kahel" "põhjusel" "."


Input: "71" "." "Esiteks" "peab" "paika" "," "et" "J" "." "Römeri" "staatus" "maksustamisel" "oli" "kindlaks" "määratud" "enne" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ülevõtmistähtaja" "lõppu" "," "nii" "et" "selles" "mõttes" "oli" "tegu" "„" "lõpliku" "“" "otsusega" "."


Input: "Siiski" "oli" "asjakohastes" "liikmesriigi" "õigusnormides" "ette" "nähtud" "," "et" "isiku" "kohtlemine" "maksustamisel" "vaadatakse" "uuesti" "läbi" "," "kui" "isiklik" "olukord" "muutub" "."


Input: "Seetõttu" "," "nagu" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "on" "kinnitanud" "," "tuleb" "vastavalt" "kohaldatavatele" "liikmesriigi" "õigusnormidele" "„" "juhul" "," "kui" "[" "soodsama" "maksualase" "liigituse" "kohaldamise" "]" "tingimused" "on" "täidetud" "alles" "pärast" "vanaduspensioni" "maksmise" "algust" "," "asjaomase" "isiku" "vastava" "taotluse" "puhul" "kohaldada" "seda" "sätet" "alates" "sellest" "kuupäevast" "“" "." "(" "36" ")"


Input: "72" "." "Seega" "oli" "kohtuasjas" "Römer" "olemas" "mehhanism" "uute" "otsuste" "vastuvõtmiseks" "," "võttes" "arvesse" "uusi" "ja" "sotsiaalkindlustust" "puudutavate" "arvutuste" "seisukohast" "asjakohaseid" "muutusi" "isiklikus" "olukorras" "."


Input: "73" "." "Teiseks" "ja" "sügavamas" "plaanis" "," "kui" "eespool" "mainitud" "uuesti" "läbivaatamise" "klausel" "kõrvale" "jätta" "," "puudutab" "kohtuotsus" "Römer" "seda" "," "kuidas" "uued" "õigusnormid" "(" "direktiiv" "2000" "/" "78" ")" "võiksid" "olla" "kohaldatavad" "isiku" "praegusele" "isiklikule" "olukorrale" "," "et" "uuesti" "läbi" "vaadata" "otsus" "nende" "pensioniõiguste" "kohta" "."


Input: "74" "." "Minu" "arvates" "on" "see" "täiesti" "erinev" "sedalaadi" "ajalisest" "kohaldamisest" "," "mida" "kassaator" "käesolevas" "kohtuasjas" "taotleb" "."


Input: "Käesolevas" "asjas" "on" "välja" "pakutud" "mitte" "isikliku" "olukorra" "(" "seadusega" "ette" "nähtud" ")" "arvessevõtmine" "tulevaste" "korrektsioonide" "eesmärgil" "," "vaid" "palju" "aastaid" "tagasi" "tekkinud" "suletud" "faktiliste" "asjaolude" "kogumi" "ja" "nendega" "seoses" "tehtud" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "uuesti" "läbivaatamine" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "arvesse" "võttes" "," "eesmärgiga" "muuta" "pensioniõigustega" "seotud" "järelmõju" "."


Input: "c" ")" "Erandid" "reeglist" "?"


Input: "75" "." "Tõepoolest" "eksisteerib" "üksikuid" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "otsuseid" "," "kus" "pensioni" "määramise" "otsus" "ja" "kõik" "olulised" "faktilised" "asjaolud" "näivad" "olevat" "uutele" "õigusnormidele" "eelnenud" "."


Input: "Teisisõnu" "on" "tehtud" "otsus" "määrata" "(" "või" "jätta" "määramata" ")" "pension" "ja" "vastav" "õiguse" "tase" "," "kuid" "uutele" "õigusnormidele" "tuginetakse" "selle" "otsuse" "uuesti" "läbivaatamise" "algatamiseks" "," "ilma" "et" "esineks" "uusi" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "ega" "muutusi" "isiklikus" "olukorras" "."


Input: "76" "." "Praktikas" "on" "sellised" "kohtuotsused" "siiski" "haruldased" "ja" "lähemal" "vaatlusel" "on" "võimalik" "neid" "hõlpsasti" "eristada" "."


Input: "Kohtuasjas" "P" "(" "37" ")" "oli" "kaebaja" "lahutanud" "abielu" "komisjoni" "ametnikuga" "."


Input: "Ametniku" "surma" "ajal" "ei" "olnud" "P‑l" "õigust" "toitjakaotuspensionile" "," "sest" "lahutusega" "seotud" "„" "süü" "“" "ei" "langenud" "ainult" "surnud" "abikaasale" "."


Input: "Vaid" "mõni" "kuu" "pärast" "tema" "surma" "jõustusid" "uued" "õigusnormid" "," "mille" "kohaselt" "oleks" "P‑l" "olnud" "õigus" "saada" "toitjakaotuspensioni" "." "(" "38" ")" "Sisuliselt" "kohaldas" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "," "mis" "andsid" "P‑le" "õiguse" "saada" "pensioni" "alates" "nende" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumiskuupäevast" "."


Input: "77" "." "Kohtuasjas" "P" "olid" "siiski" "mõned" "erisused" "."

"O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Õigupoolest" "esitas" "komisjon" "jõuliselt" "argumente" "uute" "õigusnormide" "kohaldamise" "poolt" "(" "ta" "vaidles" "pensioni" "maksmisele" "vastu" "teistel" "põhjendustel" ")" "."


Input: "Teised" "institutsioonid" "kohaldasid" "neid" "õigusnorme" "viivitamata" "ning" "selle" "tegemata" "jätmine" "oleks" "komisjoni" "sõnul" "põhjustanud" "ametnike" "vahelist" "diskrimineerimist" "."


Input: "Samuti" "tehti" "P‑le" "pensioni" "määramata" "jätmise" "otsus" "tegelikult" "mõni" "päev" "pärast" "(" "ehkki" "tema" "eksabikaasa" "oli" "surnud" "enne" ")" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "."


Input: "78" "." "Kohtuasjas" "Brock" "oli" "kaebajale" "määratud" "1958" "." "aastal" "invaliidsuspension" "."

"O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Aastal" "1961" "muudeti" "see" "vanaduspensioniks" "." "(" "39" ")" "Küsimus" "oli" "sisuliselt" "selles" "," "kas" "uued" "õigusnormid" "," "mis" "kohustasid" "arvesse" "võtma" "teistes" "liikmesriikides" "tehtud" "sissemakseid" "ja" "jõustusid" "1" "." "jaanuaril" "1964" "," "olid" "kohaldatavad" "."

"O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Euroopa" "Kohus" "tunnistas" "need" "kohaldatavaks" "."


Input: "79" "." "Minu" "arvates" "väärib" "tähelepanu" "," "et" "nimetatud" "kohtuasjas" "sisaldas" "asjakohane" "õigusakt" "sätet" "," "milles" "oli" "sõnaselgelt" "ette" "nähtud" "enne" "selle" "õigusakti" "jõustumist" "arvutatud" "pensionide" "uuesti" "läbivaatamine" "."


Input: "80" "." "Kõige" "olulisem" "asjaolu" "," "mille" "poolest" "kohtuasjad" "P" "ja" "Brock" "käesolevast" "asjast" "erinevad" "," "on" "aga" "see" "," "et" "esimesena" "nimetatud" "kohtuasjades" "puudutasid" "asjakohased" "otsused" "uute" "õigusnormide" "kohaselt" "pensioni" "määramise" "tingimuste" "hindamist" "."


Input: "81" "." "On" "ilmne" "," "et" "see" "ei" "ole" "sama" "mis" "varasema" "käitumise" "hindamine" "uute" "õigusnormide" "alusel" "eesmärgiga" "kindlaks" "teha" "," "kui" "erinev" "oleks" "olnud" "(" "distsiplinaar" ")" "otsus" "," "ja" "selle" "järelmõju" "edaspidistele" "pensioniõigustele" "."


Input: "82" "." "Nii" "näiteks" "ei" "taotlenud" "lahutatud" "abikaasa" "kohtuasjas" "P" "oma" "lahutuse" "suhtes" "uue" "hinnangu" "andmist" "," "et" "kindlaks" "teha" "," "kas" "vastutus" "lasub" "üksnes" "tema" "eksabikaasal" "."


Input: "Kohtuasjas" "Brock" "ei" "taotlenud" "töövõimetuks" "jäänud" "isik" "oma" "õnnetuse" "asjaolude" "suhtes" "uue" "hinnangu" "andmist" "," "et" "kindlaks" "teha" "," "kas" "selle" "saab" "liigitada" "tööõnnetuseks" "."


Input: "Kumbki" "otsus" "," "mis" "käsitles" "vastutust" "lahutuse" "või" "õnnetuse" "eest" "," "oli" "lõplik" "," "nii" "nagu" "on" "käesolevas" "asjas" "lõplik" "ka" "distsiplinaarotsus" "."


Input: "83" "." "Kokkuvõttes" "tunduvad" "niisugused" "kohtuotsused" "nagu" "P" "või" "Brock" "esmapilgul" "„" "tagasiulatuvamad" "“" "kui" "teised" "juhtumid" "," "nagu" "need" "," "mida" "on" "käsitletud" "eespool" "."


Input: "Ent" "kui" "jätta" "kõrvale" "see" "," "et" "tegu" "on" "suhteliselt" "vanade" "ja" "eraldiseisvate" "kohtuasjadega" "," "saab" "neid" "käesolevast" "asjast" "ikkagi" "selgelt" "eristada" "."


Input: "Igal" "juhul" "on" "minu" "arvates" "selge" "," "et" "selliseid" "kohtuotsuseid" "ei" "saa" "tõlgendada" "nii" "," "et" "uute" "õigusnormide" "vastuvõtmisest" "tekib" "absoluutne" "õigus" "nõuda" "muidu" "lõplikuks" "muutunud" "varasemate" "haldusotsuste" "uuesti" "läbivaatamist" "neid" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "arvesse" "võttes" "ja" "sellele" "vastavalt" "pensionimaksete" "muutmist" "."


Input: "d" ")" "Üleminekusätted"


Input: "84" "." "Lõpuks" "on" "veel" "üks" "pensioneid" "käsitlev" "kohtupraktika" "suund" "," "mis" "märkimist" "väärib" "," "seotud" "direktiiviga" "79" "/" "7" "/" "EMÜ" "." "(" "40" ")" "See" "direktiiv" "kohustas" "liikmesriike" "rakendama" "meeste" "ja" "naiste" "võrdse" "kohtlemise" "põhimõtet" "sotsiaalkindlustuse" "valdkonnas" "."


Input: "Selle" "protsessi" "raames" "muutsid" "liikmesriigid" "riigisiseseid" "õigusnorme" "kindlustushüvitiste" "kohta" "," "et" "kaotada" "sooline" "diskrimineerimine" "."


Input: "85" "." "Nende" "seadusandlike" "muudatuste" "tagajärjel" "esitati" "Euroopa" "Kohtule" "mitu" "eelotsusetaotlust" "."


Input: "Käesolevas" "asjas" "olulises" "osas" "puudutasid" "need" "juhtumid" "naissoost" "kaebajaid" "," "kellele" "oli" "diskrimineerivate" "riigisiseste" "õigusnormide" "tõttu" "keeldutud" "määramast" "sotsiaalkindlustushüvitisi" "otsusega" "," "mis" "oli" "vastu" "võetud" "enne" "direktiivi" "ülevõtmise" "tähtpäeva" "."


Input: "Sisuliselt" "taotlesid" "nad" "nende" "hüvitiste" "saamist" "pärast" "direktiivi" "ülevõtmise" "tähtpäeva" "uute" "," "mittediskrimineerivate" "õigusnormide" "alusel" "."


Input: "86" "." "Euroopa" "Kohus" "kinnitas" "oma" "otsustes" "korduvalt" "," "et" "diskrimineerimise" "tagajärjed" "tuleb" "pärast" "direktiivi" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "möödumist" "likvideerida" "."


Input: "Lähemal" "vaatlusel" "aga" "on" "need" "juhtumid" "käesoleva" "asjaga" "võrreldes" "jällegi" "väga" "teistsugused" "."


Input: "87" "." "Näiteks" "kohtuasjas" "Borrie" "Clarke" "(" "41" ")" "oli" "liikmesriigi" "õiguses" "kehtestatud" "invaliidsuspensioni" "taotlevate" "naiste" "suhtes" "lisatingimus" "," "mis" "meeste" "kohta" "ei" "käinud" "(" "võimetus" "teha" "koduseid" "töid" ")" "."


Input: "Kaebaja" "sellele" "lisatingimusele" "ei" "vastanud" "ja" "tema" "pensionitaotlus" "jäeti" "1983" "." "aastal" "rahuldamata" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Direktiivi" "järgimise" "eesmärgil" "muudeti" "seejärel" "liikmesriigi" "õigusnorme" "."


Input: "Invaliidsuspension" "asendati" "puudetoetusega" "ning" "kehtestati" "uued" "tingimused" "," "mis" "olid" "ühesugused" "mõlema" "soo" "jaoks" "."


Input: "Ülemineku" "raames" "aga" "said" "isikud" "," "kellele" "oli" "enne" "uut" "seadust" "määratud" "invaliidsuspension" "," "automaatselt" "puudetoetust" "," "ilma" "et" "nad" "pidanuksid" "uutele" "tingimustele" "vastama" "."


Input: "Seega" "taaskinnitasid" "ja" "põlistasid" "üleminekusätted" "tegelikult" "diskrimineerimist" "."


Input: "88" "." "Euroopa" "Kohus" "märkis" "," "et" "„" "kui" "alates" "[" "üleminekuaja" "lõpust" "]" "oli" "mehel" "," "kes" "oli" "samasuguses" "olukorras" "nagu" "naine" "," "eespool" "nimetatud" "üleminekusätete" "alusel" "automaatselt" "õigus" "saada" "uut" "tõsise" "puude" "toetust" "," "ilma" "et" "ta" "oleks" "pidanud" "oma" "õigusi" "uuesti" "tõendama" "," "oli" "õigus" "saada" "seda" "toetust" "ka" "naisel" "," "ilma" "et" "ta" "oleks" "pidanud" "täitma" "lisatingimuse" "," "mida" "kohaldati" "enne" "seda" "kuupäeva" "üksnes" "abielunaiste" "suhtes" "“" "." "(" "42" ")"


Input: "89" "." "Minu" "arvates" "sarnaneb" "kohtuasjas" "Borrie" "Clarke" "käsitletud" "olukord" "teiste" "pensionialaste" "kohtuasjadega" "," "mida" "on" "eespool" "A" "jaos" "juba" "käsitletud" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Sisuliselt" "kujutasid" "üleminekusätted" "endast" "diskrimineerivate" "õigusnormide" "uut" "kohaldamist" "tuleviku" "suhtes" "(" "või" "vähemalt" "varasema" "otsuse" "pikendamist" "uute" "õigusnormide" "alusel" ")" "."


Input: "Seetõttu" "on" "seegi" "kohtupraktika" "suund" "käesolevast" "asjast" "selgelt" "eristatav" "."


Input: "90" "." "Samalaadset" "olukorda" "võib" "kohata" "teisteski" "kohtuotsustes" "," "mis" "on" "," "tõsi" "küll" "," "seotud" "teist" "laadi" "hüvitistega" "." "(" "43" ")"


Input: "3" "." "Jätkuvad" "suhted"


Input: "91" "." "Komisjon" "viitas" "oma" "kirjalikes" "seisukohtades" "ka" "kohtuasjale" "Österreicher" "Gewerkschaftsbund" "," "(" "44" ")" "tõmmates" "paralleeli" "jätkuva" "diskrimineerimisega" "kuupalga" "väljamaksmisel" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "See" "haakub" "kassaatori" "argumentidega" "," "milles" "on" "korduvalt" "viidatud" "jätkuvale" "diskrimineerimisele" "," "mis" "seisneb" "regulaarselt" "tehtavates" "vähendatud" "pensionimaksetes" "."


Input: "92" "." "Niivõrd" "kui" "viidetes" "sellele" "kohtupraktika" "suunale" "võib" "näha" "toetavat" "argumenti" "," "mis" "erineb" "eelnevas" "jaos" "käsitletust" "," "ei" "mõista" "ma" "," "kuidas" "see" "saaks" "kassaatori" "väidetele" "kaasa" "aidata" "."


Input: "Minu" "arvates" "on" "jällegi" "tegu" "lihtsalt" "teistsuguse" "kohtupraktikaga" "."


Input: "93" "." "Kohtuasjas" "Österreicher" "Gewerkschaftsbund" "(" "45" ")" "võeti" "Austria" "õiguse" "kohaselt" "lepinguliste" "õpetajate" "töötasu" "arvutamisel" "täiel" "määral" "arvesse" "varasemaid" "Austrias" "omandatud" "pedagoogilisi" "kogemusi" "."


Input: "Teistes" "liikmesriikides" "omandatud" "pedagoogilisi" "kogemusi" "võeti" "arvesse" "vaid" "piiratud" "ulatuses" "."


Input: "Euroopa" "Kohus" "asus" "seisukohale" "," "et" "see" "piirang" "on" "vastuolus" "töötajate" "vaba" "liikumisega" "."


Input: "Samuti" "otsustas" "ta" "," "et" "diskrimineerimise" "heastamiseks" "tuleb" "teistes" "liikmesriikides" "omandatud" "pedagoogilisi" "kogemusi" "arvesse" "võtta" "täielikult" "," "isegi" "kui" "need" "kogemused" "on" "omandatud" "enne" "," "kui" "Austria" "liiduga" "ühines" "."


Input: "94" "." "Õieti" "on" "Österreicher" "Gewerkschaftsbund" "üks" "mitmest" "kohtuotsusest" "," "kus" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "on" "sisuliselt" "asunud" "seisukohale" "," "et" "töösuhetes" "võib" "töötajate" "palga" "kindlaksmääramisel" "olla" "vaja" "arvesse" "võtta" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumisele" "eelnenud" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "," "kui" "need" "on" "uue" "õigusliku" "regulatsiooni" "alusel" "selle" "hinnangu" "andmisel" "asjakohased" "." "(" "46" ")" "Nii" "näiteks" "märkis" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "reas" "kohtuotsustes" "alates" "kohtuasjast" "Hütter" "," "et" "Austria" "õigusnormid" "," "milles" "võeti" "ametnike" "palgaastmete" "kindlaksmääramisel" "arvesse" "enne" "18aastaseks" "saamist" "omandatud" "kutsealaseid" "kogemusi" "," "on" "vastuolus" "direktiivis" "2000" "/" "78" "sätestatud" "vanuselise" "diskrimineerimise" "keeluga" "." "(" "47" ")" "Palgaastmeid" "tuli" "diskrimineerimise" "kaotamiseks" "korrigeerida" "," "sealhulgas" "ka" "siis" "," "kui" "asjakohased" "kogemused" "olid" "omandatud" "enne" "selle" "direktiivi" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "möödumist" "."


Input: "95" "." "Minu" "arvates" "ei" "ole" "võimalik" "tõmmata" "otseseid" "paralleele" "käesoleva" "kohtuasja" "ja" "niisuguste" "kohtuasjade" "vahel" "," "mis" "puudutavad" "palkade" "korrigeerimist" "diskrimineerimise" "heastamise" "eesmärgil" "," "ja" "seda" "lihtsal" "põhjusel" ":" "sellistes" "kohtuasjades" "nagu" "Österreicher" "Gewerkschaftsbund" "töösuhe" "jätkus" "," "mõlemal" "poolel" "olid" "vastastikku" "õigused" "ja" "kohustused" "."


Input: "Töötajal" "on" "palga" "-" "või" "ametiaste" "ja" "teatava" "arvu" "aastate" "jagu" "asjakohaseid" "kogemusi" "," "mida" "võetakse" "igal" "kuul" "aluseks" "tema" "palga" "arvutamisel" "."


Input: "Seega" "igal" "kuul" "olukord" "„" "uueneb" "“" "," "kehtivaid" "seadusi" "kohaldatakse" "asjakohastes" "palgaarvutustes" "uuesti" "," "tehes" "igal" "juhul" "jätkuvaid" "korrektsioone" "vastavalt" "uutele" "seadustele" "ja" "isikliku" "olukorra" "muutustele" "." "(" "48" ")" "See" "sarnaneb" "mõneti" "olukorraga" "kohtuasjas" "Römer" "," "kus" "hageja" "isikliku" "olukorra" "muutumisega" "seotud" "seadusandlikud" "sätted" "võimaldasid" "samalaadset" "„" "uuendamist" "“" "." "(" "49" ")"


Input: "96" "." "Käesoleva" "kohtuasja" "sugustes" "kohtuasjades" "oli" "töösuhe" "seevastu" "lõppenud" "(" "50" ")" "," "kõik" "pensioniõigused" "juba" "enne" "seda" "aega" "kumuleerunud" "ning" "distsiplinaarotsus" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "kohta" "oli" "tehtud" "1975" "." "aastal" "varasemate" "sündmuste" "põhjal" "ja" "lõplikuks" "muutunud" "."


Input: "Selle" "otsuse" "praktilised" "tagajärjed" "on" "jätkuvalt" "tuntavad" "," "nagu" "see" "võib" "olla" "mis" "tahes" "minevikusündmuse" "puhul" "," "kuid" "enam" "ei" "eksisteeri" "jätkuvat" "suhet" "," "mis" "eeldaks" "uue" "hinnangu" "andmist" "uute" "õigusnormide" "alusel" "."


Input: "Jätkuvalt" "asjakohaseid" "minevikus" "tekkinud" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "ei" "ole" "."


Input: "Selles" "mõttes" "on" "minevikus" "tekkinud" "faktiliste" "asjaolude" "õiguslikud" "tagajärjed" "tõepoolest" "ammendatud" "."


Input: "4" "." "Varasemate" "otsuste" "uuesti" "menetlusse" "võtmine"


Input: "97" "." "Lõpuks" "tuleks" "täieliku" "ülevaate" "huvides" "lisada" "," "et" "liidu" "õiguses" "on" "lisaks" "reeglitele" "," "mis" "käsitlevad" "uute" "õigusnormide" "ajalist" "kohaldatavust" "minevikus" "tekkinud" "faktilistele" "asjaoludele" "ja" "/" "või" "jätkuvatele" "õigussuhetele" "," "olemas" "ka" "piiratud" "kohustus" "varasemad" "otsused" "uuesti" "menetlusse" "võtta" "," "kui" "need" "on" "liidu" "õigusega" "vastuolus" "."


Input: "98" "." "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "praktikas" "on" "toonitatud" "res" "judicata" "põhimõtte" "tähtsust" "õigusrahu" "ja" "õigussuhete" "stabiilsuse" "," "aga" "ka" "korrakohase" "õigusemõistmise" "seisukohast" "."


Input: "Otsuseid" "," "mis" "on" "pärast" "kõikide" "kaebeõiguste" "ammendamist" "või" "sellekohaste" "tähtaegade" "möödumist" "jõustunud" "," "ei" "saa" "enam" "vaidlustada" "." "(" "51" ")" "See" "on" "nii" "isegi" "juhul" "," "kui" "vaidlustamine" "võimaldaks" "liikmesriigi" "kohtul" "heastada" "vaidlusalusest" "otsusest" "põhjustatud" "liidu" "õiguse" "rikkumise" "." "(" "52" ")"


Input: "99" "." "Õigupoolest" "võib" "jõustunud" "otsuseid" "uuesti" "menetlusse" "võtta" "," "kuid" "ainult" "tõesti" "erandlikel" "asjaoludel" "."


Input: "Nende" "asjaolude" "hulka" "kuulub" "see" "," "kui" "liidu" "õigust" "on" "vääralt" "tõlgendatud" "ilma" "Euroopa" "Kohtult" "eelotsust" "taotlemata" "ning" "asjaomane" "isik" "on" "esitanud" "haldusasutusele" "kaebuse" "kohe" "," "kui" "ta" "on" "sellest" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "otsusest" "teada" "saanud" "." "(" "53" ")"


Input: "100" "." "Ent" "kui" "jätta" "kõrvale" "küsimus" "," "kus" "täpselt" "asetseb" "„" "erandlikkuse" "“" "künnis" "," "oli" "nende" "väheste" "selle" "kohustuse" "rakendamise" "juhtude" "ühine" "nimetaja" "loomulikult" "see" "," "et" "vastuolu" "oli" "liikmesriigi" "tasandil" "otsuse" "tegemise" "ajal" "juba" "olemas" "."


Input: "Seega" "rikkus" "juba" "algne" "otsus" "liidu" "õigust" "."


Input: "101" "." "Seevastu" "käesolevas" "asjas" "ei" "olnud" "Austria" "sel" "ajal" "," "kui" "asjasse" "puutuvad" "otsused" "(" "nii" "distsiplinaarotsus" "kui" "ka" "kassaatorile" "pensioni" "määramise" "otsus" ")" "tehti" "," "liikmesriik" "ning" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ei" "olnud" "veel" "vastu" "võetud" "."


Input: "Samuti" "oli" "distsiplinaarotsus" "1974" "." "aastal" "," "mil" "see" "vastu" "võeti" "," "Austria" "valitsuse" "sõnul" "–" "millele" "kassaator" "ei" "ole" "vastu" "vaielnud" "–" "riigisisese" "õigusega" "kooskõlas" "."


Input: "102" "." "Seetõttu" "ei" "ole" "erandlikke" "asjaolusid" "," "mis" "põhjendaksid" "käesoleval" "juhul" "lõplikuks" "muutunud" "haldusotsuste" "uuesti" "menetlusse" "võtmist" "," "veel" "vähem" "midagi" "," "mis" "põhjendaks" "üldisemat" "ja" "kaugeleulatuvat" "otsust" "liidu" "õiguse" "ajalise" "kohaldamise" "kohta" "sama" "tulemuse" "saavutamise" "eesmärgil" "."


Input: "5" "." "Kohaldamine" "käesolevas" "asjas"


Input: "103" "." "Teen" "eespool" "tutvustatud" "eri" "kohtupraktika" "suundadest" "järgmised" "põhijäreldused" "."


Input: "104" "." "Esiteks" "keskendub" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "praktika" "," "mis" "käsitleb" "uute" "õigusnormide" "ajalist" "mõju" "ja" "pensioniõigusi" "," "väga" "paljuski" "olukordadele" "," "kus" "pensioniõigus" "otsustati" "pärast" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "."


Input: "105" "." "Teiseks" "ei" "saa" "kohtupraktikat" "," "mis" "käsitleb" "jätkuvaid" "(" "töö" ")" "suhteid" "ning" "palgaastmete" "ja" "kuupalkade" "korrigeerimist" "," "üle" "kanda" "(" "ammu" ")" "enne" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "välja" "arvutatud" "ja" "välja" "makstud" "pensionide" "maksmisele" "."


Input: "106" "." "Kolmandaks" "ei" "ole" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "praktikas" "kindlat" "alust" "kaugeleulatuvale" "arvamusele" "," "et" "enne" "uute" "õigusnormide" "jõustumist" "lõplikuks" "muutunud" "haldusotsuse" "jätkuv" "mõju" "pensionimaksetele" "tuleb" "uuesti" "läbi" "vaadata" "," "võttes" "arvesse" "seda" "," "kuidas" "neid" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "oleks" "kohaldatud" "."


Input: "Pealegi" "on" "selline" "arvamus" "vastuolus" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "väljakujunenud" "praktikaga" "res" "judicata" "teemal" "."


Input: "107" "." "Olen" "juba" "püüdnud" "eristada" "käesolevat" "kohtuasja" "ja" "selgitada" "," "miks" "see" "ei" "kuulu" "ühessegi" "eespool" "asjakohastes" "jagudes" "käsitletud" "kategooriasse" "."


Input: "Kokkuvõttes" "olen" "seisukohal" "," "et" "käesoleval" "juhul" "oli" "sunniviisiline" "pensionile" "saatmine" "ja" "vähendatud" "pensioniõiguse" "määramine" "juba" "enne" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "lõppu" "muutunud" "eespool" "punktis" "46" "osundatud" "kohtupraktika" "tähenduses" "„" "lõplikult" "välja" "kujunenud" "olukorraks" "“" "."


Input: "Seda" "," "et" "kassaatorile" "tehakse" "jätkuvalt" "pensionimakseid" "," "ei" "saa" "pidada" "enne" "seda" "direktiivi" "tekkinud" "olukorra" "„" "tulevikus" "tekkivateks" "tagajärgedeks" "“" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "praktika" "tähenduses" "nii" "," "et" "need" "tuleks" "välistada" "või" "neid" "tuleks" "muuta" "."


Input: "108" "." "Distsiplinaarotsus" "vaidlustati" "juba" "1970" "." "aastatel" "," "kuid" "edutult" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Õigusküsimus" "," "mis" "puudutas" "kassaatori" "staatust" "pensionile" "jäänud" "politseiametnikuna" "," "ja" "tema" "pensioni" "vähendamine" "olid" "selleks" "ajaks" "otsustatud" "."


Input: "Kassaator" "on" "saanud" "pensioni" "alates" "1976" "." "aastast" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"


Input: "Ei" "ole" "ühtegi" "uut" "otsust" "," "mis" "oleks" "tehtud" "või" "oleks" "tulnud" "teha" "pärast" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "möödumist" "."


Input: "109" "." "Pealegi" "tekkisid" "käesoleval" "juhul" "kõik" "olulised" "asjaolud" "," "millel" "distsiplinaarotsus" "põhines" "," "1970" "." "aastatel" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"


Input: "Nii" "ei" "ole" "kassaatori" "praeguses" "isiklikus" "olukorras" "–" "erinevalt" "olukorrast" "kohtuasjas" "Römer" "–" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "," "mida" "tuleks" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "kohaselt" "uuesti" "hinnata" "."


Input: "110" "." "Ma" "ei" "arva" "," "et" "sellised" "kohtuasjad" "nagu" "Brock" "ja" "P" "saaksid" "anda" "alust" "üldiseks" "seisukohaks" "," "et" "on" "olemas" "õigus" "pensionimaksete" "uuesti" "läbivaatamisele" "," "mis" "seisneks" "uute" "õigusnormide" "tagasiulatuvas" "kohaldamises" "varasemale" "otsusele" "," "mis" "mõjutab" "õigust" "saada" "neid" "makseid" "ja" "nende" "taset" "."


Input: "Samuti" "olid" "kohtuasjad" "Brock" "ja" "P" "minu" "arvates" "väga" "erinevad" "võrreldes" "käesoleva" "asjaga" "."

"O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Mõlemal" "nimetatud" "juhul" "oli" "varasemat" "haldusotsust" "tehes" "kohaldatud" "üsna" "konkreetseid" "ja" "objektiivseid" "tingimusi" "seoses" "pensioni" "saamise" "õiguse" "ja" "tasemega" "."


Input: "Hilisemates" "seadusemuudatustes" "neid" "tingimusi" "muudeti" "."


Input: "See" "erineb" "käesolevast" "kohtuasjast" "," "kus" "sisuliselt" "palutakse" "uuesti" "algatada" "40" "aasta" "tagune" "distsiplinaarmenetlus" "," "lähtudes" "uutest" "diskrimineerimisalastest" "õigusnormidest" "," "ja" "kvalitatiivselt" "hinnata" "," "kas" "ja" "kuidas" "see" "otsus" "oleks" "muutunud" "."


Input: "111" "." "Kassaator" "on" "oma" "seisukohtades" "rõhutanud" "diskrimineerimise" "„" "jätkumist" "“" "vähendatud" "igakuiste" "maksete" "kujul" "."


Input: "Kohtuasjadest" "," "mis" "on" "käsitlenud" "tegelikke" "jätkuvaid" "õigussuhteid" "ja" "vajadust" "neid" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "arvesse" "võttes" "järk-järgult" "kohandada" "," "nagu" "Österreicher" "Gewerkschaftsbund" "või" "Römer" "," "aga" "nähtub" "," "et" "pelgalt" "1975" "." "ja" "1976" "." "aastal" "tehtud" "lõplikel" "otsustel" "põhinevate" "igakuiste" "maksete" "saamine" "ei" "eelda" "uue" "hinnangu" "andmist" "ühegi" "asjasse" "puutuva" "faktilise" "asjaolu" "kohta" "."


Input: "112" "." "Tegelikult" "on" "käesolevas" "asjas" "palutud" "varasemat" "lõplikku" "distsiplinaarotsust" "uuesti" "hinnata" "," "kohaldades" "uusi" "diskrimineerimiskeelu" "standardeid" "," "et" "teha" "kindlaks" "järelmõju" "igakuistele" "pensionimaksetele" "."


Input: "Seda" "," "mida" "tegelikult" "taotletakse" "," "kirjeldab" "ehk" "kõige" "paremini" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "esimese" "küsimuse" "viimase" "lause" "saksakeelne" "sõnastus" "," "milles" "on" "viidatud" "uut" "liiki" "„" "gedachte" "“" "otsuse" "tegemisele" "," "mis" "rikuks" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "," "kui" "see" "oleks" "tehtud" "selle" "direktiivi" "jõusoleku" "ajal" "."


Input: "Gedachte" "võib" "tõlkida" "kui" "„" "mõeldav" "“" "," "kuid" "selle" "tegelik" "tähendus" "käesolevas" "kontekstis" "on" "pigem" "(" "täiesti" ")" "„" "kujutletav" "“" "."


Input: "113" "." "Minu" "arvates" "on" "selge" "," "et" "niisugusel" "juhul" "nagu" "käesolev" "ei" "taga" "liidu" "õigus" "isikutele" "õigust" "nõuda" "," "et" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "arvesse" "võttes" "vaadataks" "uuesti" "läbi" "nende" "kohta" "nende" "eluajal" "tehtud" "haldusotsus" "," "mis" "on" "mõjutanud" "või" "võinud" "mõjutada" "ebasoodsalt" "nende" "pensioni" "(" "või" "muid" "hüvitisi" ")" "."


Input: "Liidu" "õiguses" "lihtsalt" "ei" "ole" "selliseks" "kaugeleulatuvaks" "väiteks" "alust" "."


Input: "114" "." "Lõpuks" "," "et" "oleksid" "käsitletud" "kõik" "kassaatori" "argumendid" "," "sisaldavad" "tema" "seisukohad" "palju" "sügavamat" "moraalset" "argumenti" "," "mis" "osaliselt" "põimub" "uute" "õigusnormide" "ajalist" "kohaldamist" "puudutava" "„" "tehnilise" "“" "argumendiga" "," "kuid" "on" "osalt" "ka" "sellest" "sõltumatu" "."


Input: "Kui" "vaadata" "seda" "eraldi" "," "nagu" "kassaator" "kohtuistungil" "soovitas" "," "ei" "olene" "see" "argument" "paljuski" "1975" "." "aasta" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "võimalikust" "uuesti" "läbivaatamisest" "."


Input: "Selle" "kohaselt" "oleks" "Austriale" "etteheidetav" "mitte" "see" "," "et" "ta" "on" "jätnud" "mineviku" "uuesti" "läbi" "vaatamata" "," "vaid" "see" "," "et" "ta" "ei" "ole" "aktiivselt" "ja" "edasiulatuvalt" "heastanud" "varasemat" "õigusvastast" "tegevust" "pärast" "2003" "." "aastat" "," "mil" "direktiiv" "2000" "/" "78" "oli" "juba" "jõus" "ja" "EIK" "tegi" "kohtuotsused" "Austria" "vastu" "." "(" "54" ")"


Input: "115" "." "Selles" "suhtes" "märgiksin" "lihtsalt" "uuesti" "," "et" "ma" "ei" "näe" "liidu" "õiguses" "sellist" "kohustust" "."


Input: "Direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "artikkel" "17" "," "mille" "kohaselt" "peavad" "liikmesriigid" "kehtestama" "tõhusad" "," "proportsionaalsed" "ja" "hoiatavad" "sanktsioonid" "," "on" "ise" "loogiliselt" "seotud" "sellesama" "direktiivi" "ajalise" "kohaldatavusega" "."


Input: "116" "." "Pealegi" "tehakse" "haldusotsused" "oma" "aja" "konkreetses" "kontekstis" "."


Input: "Karistusõiguslikud" "," "distsiplinaarõiguslikud" "ja" "moraalsed" "olud" "on" "Austrias" "," "nagu" "ka" "mujal" "Euroopas" "," "alates" "1975" "." "aastast" "palju" "muutunud" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Nii" "näiteks" "määratakse" "Austrias" "nüüd" "distsiplinaarkaristusi" "ainult" "nendele" "politseiametnikele" "," "kelle" "teod" "õõnestavad" "üldsuse" "usaldust" "politsei" "vastu" "."


Input: "Kriminaalkorras" "süüdimõistmine" "aga" "viib" "automaatse" "töölt" "vallandamiseni" "–" "nagu" "aru" "saan" "," "üldse" "ilma" "pensioniõigusteta" "."


Input: "Seksuaalse" "enesemääramise" "vanusepiir" "on" "Austrias" "nüüd" "nii" "homo" "‑" "kui" "ka" "heteroseksuaalide" "jaoks" "ühtviisi" "14" "aastat" "."


Input: "Siiski" "on" "ette" "nähtud" "sõnaselged" "erandid" "alla" "16aastaste" "laste" "suhtes" "," "keda" "ei" "peeta" "piisavalt" "küpseks" "."


Input: "117" "." "Kokkuvõttes" "," "moraal" "on" "liikumises" "."


Input: "Peale" "selle" "on" "moraalsed" "argumendid" "sageli" "nagu" "kaheteraline" "mõõk" "."


Input: "Keerukate" "faktiliste" "asjaoludega" "juhtumite" "puhul" "," "kus" "on" "vaja" "teha" "mitmeid" "moraalseid" "otsustusi" "," "nagu" "käesolevas" "asjas" "," "võib" "see" "lõigata" "mõlemas" "suunas" "."


Input: "Seetõttu" "–" "välja" "arvatud" "äärmuslikel" "juhtudel" "," "kui" "on" "tegu" "üldinimlike" "väärtuste" "ilmse" "ja" "jultunud" "eiramisega" "," "millega" "võib" "kaasneda" "moraalne" "kohustus" "heastada" "varasem" "õigusvastasus" "olenemata" "ajast" "(" "55" ")" "–" "tuleks" "ühiskondadel" "ja" "nende" "seadustel" "võimaldada" "edasi" "areneda" "järk-järgult" "," "jättes" "mineviku" "minevikku" "."


Input: "6" "." "Järeldus" "esimeses" "küsimuses"


Input: "118" "." "Eelnevat" "arvesse" "võttes" "teen" "ettepaneku" "vastata" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "esimesele" "küsimusele" "järgmiselt" ":"


Input: "Direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "artikliga" "2" "ei" "ole" "vastuolus" "olukord" "," "kus" "ametnike" "distsiplinaarvastutust" "käsitlevate" "õigusnormide" "alusel" "tehtud" "haldusotsus" "(" "distsiplinaarotsus" ")" "," "mis" "on" "liikmesriigi" "õiguse" "alusel" "muutunud" "lõplikuks" "ja" "millega" "ametnik" "saadeti" "pensionile" "koos" "pensioni" "vähendamisega" "," "säilitab" "oma" "õigust" "kujundava" "toime" "," "kui"


Input: "–" "haldusotsuse" "tegemise" "ajal" "ei" "olnud" "liidu" "õiguse" "asjaomased" "sätted" "," "eelkõige" "direktiiv" "veel" "selle" "otsuse" "suhtes" "kohaldatavad" "," "kuid"


Input: "–" "samalaadne" "(" "mõeldav" ")" "otsus" "oleks" "direktiiviga" "vastuolus" "juhul" "," "kui" "see" "tehtaks" "direktiivi" "ajalises" "kohaldamisalas" "."


Input: "B" "." "Teine" "ja" "kolmas" "küsimus"


Input: "119" "." "Arvestades" "vastust" "," "mille" "pakkusin" "välja" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "esimesele" "küsimusele" "," "ei" "ole" "vaja" "teisele" "ega" "kolmandale" "küsimusele" "vastata" "."


Input: "Juhuks" "," "kui" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "peaks" "jõudma" "teistsugusele" "järeldusele" "," "käsitlen" "lühidalt" "ka" "neid" "küsimusi" "."


Input: "120" "." "Kui" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "otsustab" "," "et" "selle" "diskrimineeriva" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "tagajärgi" "ei" "saa" "säilitada" "," "on" "küsimus" "just" "selles" "," "mis" "kaasneb" "niisugustel" "juhtudel" "nagu" "käesolev" "sellega" "," "et" "„" "neid" "tagajärgi" "ei" "säilitata" "“" "."


Input: "121" "." "Kui" "vastust" "sellele" "küsimusele" "ei" "tule" "lahutada" "1970" "." "aastatel" "tehtud" "otsustest" "samalaadselt" "sellega" "," "mida" "olen" "äsja" "märkinud" "aktiivse" "," "edasiulatuva" "hüvitamiskohustuse" "suhtes" "(" "mis" "eeldatavasti" "hõlmab" "paušaalseid" "makseid" ")" "," "oleks" "liikmesriigi" "kohtul" "vaja" "kaaluda" "kõnealuse" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "sisu" "," "et" "teha" "kindlaks" "," "kas" "see" "võeti" "vastu" "kooskõlas" "direktiiviga" "2000" "/" "78" "," "ja" "kuupäeva" "," "millest" "alates" "oleks" "see" "uus" "kujutletav" "otsus" "kohaldatav" "."


Input: "Viitan" "sellele" "edaspidi" "kui" "mis-oleks-kui-lähenemisviisile" "."


Input: "122" "." "Minu" "arvates" "on" "40" "aasta" "vanuse" "otsuse" "ja" "selle" "tagajärgede" "rekonstrueerimine" "väga" "problemaatiline" "."


Input: "Eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "on" "siiski" "olnud" "teises" "ja" "kolmandas" "eelotsuse" "küsimuses" "üsna" "konkreetne" "sellise" "õigusliku" "fiktsiooni" "„" "süžeeliinide" "“" "osas" "."


Input: "Seetõttu" "muutuks" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "paratamatult" "selle" "kaasautoriks" "," "välja" "arvatud" "," "kui" "ta" "märgiks" "lihtsalt" "," "et" "„" "tagajärgi" "ei" "saa" "säilitada" "“" "," "ja" "jätaks" "liikmesriigi" "kohtu" "otsustada" "," "kuidas" "neid" "tagajärgi" "kindlaks" "teha" "ja" "„" "neutraliseerida" "“" "."


Input: "Pakun" "järgnevalt" "mõned" "kaalutlused" "selle" "kohta" "," "milliseks" "võib" "süžee" "kujuneda" "."


Input: "1" "." "Teine" "küsimus"


Input: "123" "." "Kõnealuse" "distsiplinaarotsusega" "saadeti" "kassaator" "enne" "ettenähtud" "aega" "pensionile" "ja" "vähendati" "tema" "pensioniõigusi" "25%" "võrra" "."


Input: "Oma" "teises" "küsimuses" "soovib" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "teada" "," "kas" "haldusotsusest" "tuleneva" "diskrimineerimise" "heastamiseks" "piisab" "sellest" "," "kui" "tühistada" "pensioni" "vähendamine" "25%" "võrra" "," "või" "tuleb" "pensioni" "arvutada" "nii" "," "nagu" "oleks" "kassaator" "tema" "pensionile" "saatmisega" "alanud" "perioodil" "töötanud" "."


Input: "Kas" "piisab" "sellest" "," "kui" "neutraliseerida" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "tulevikus" "tekkivad" "tagajärjed" "," "või" "on" "vaja" "neutraliseerida" "ka" "ennetähtaegse" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tulevikus" "tekkivad" "tagajärjed" "?"


Input: "124" "." "Kassaator" "on" "oma" "seisukohtades" "argumenteerinud" "," "et" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamine" "tuleb" "täielikult" "tühistada" "ning" "tema" "pensioniõigusi" "tuleb" "arvutada" "nii" "," "nagu" "oleks" "ta" "vahepealsel" "perioodil" "politseis" "töötanud" "."


Input: "Teisisõnu" "tuleb" "luua" "olukord" "," "mis" "oleks" "tekkinud" "," "kui" "distsiplinaarotsust" "ei" "oleks" "üldse" "tehtud" "(" "ega" "mingit" "karistust" "määratud" ")" "."


Input: "125" "." "Komisjon" "toetab" "„" "mis" "oleks" "," "kui" "“" "-" "lähenemisviisi" "ainult" "seoses" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamisega" "," "tunnistades" "," "et" "karistuseks" "kassaatori" "käitumise" "eest" "oleks" "võidud" "tema" "pensioni" "vähendada" "ka" "ilma" "homofoobse" "kallutatuseta" "."


Input: "Seevastu" "peab" "komisjon" "asjakohatuks" "rakendada" "„" "mis" "oleks" "," "kui" "“" "-" "lähenemisviisi" "pensionile" "saatmise" "küsimuses" "."


Input: "Ennetähtaegsest" "pensionile" "saatmisest" "tingitud" "pensioni" "vähendamine" "ei" "ole" "tegelikult" "minevikus" "tekkinud" "olukorra" "„" "tulevikus" "tekkiv" "tagajärg" "“" "," "millele" "tuleb" "kohaldada" "uusi" "õigusnorme" "."


Input: "Pensionile" "saatmise" "õiguslikud" "tagajärjed" "ammendusid" "komisjoni" "arvates" "siis" "," "kui" "töösuhe" "lõppes" "."


Input: "Sel" "põhjusel" "võib" "säilitada" "tagajärjed" "," "mis" "seisnevad" "ennetähtaegse" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tõttu" "pensioniõiguste" "suurenemata" "jäämises" "."


Input: "126" "." "Täheldan" "järgmist" "."


Input: "127" "." "Kui" "distsiplinaarotsus" "oleks" "1975" "." "aastal" "vastu" "võetud" "nii" "," "et" "see" "oleks" "olnud" "kooskõlas" "2000" "." "aastal" "kehtestatud" "seksuaalse" "sättumuse" "alusel" "diskrimineerimise" "keeluga" "," "ei" "ole" "selge" "," "kas" "kassaator" "oleks" "üldse" "pensionile" "saadetud" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "viidet" "„" "märkimisväärselt" "leebemale" "“" "karistusele" "(" "56" ")" "saaks" "ju" "mõista" "ka" "nii" "," "et" "kassaatorit" "ei" "olekski" "pensionile" "saadetud" "."


Input: "128" "." "Sel" "juhul" "ei" "saaks" "„" "sunniviisilise" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tulevikus" "tekkivaid" "tagajärgi" "“" "kooskõlas" "esimese" "küsimuse" "vastusega" "säilitada" "."


Input: "Kindlasti" "kuulub" "nende" "tagajärgede" "hulka" "see" "," "et" "kassaator" "ei" "töötanud" "enam" "politseis" "," "talle" "ei" "lisandunud" "enam" "pensioniõigusi" "ja" "„" "kaotatud" "aastaid" "“" "ei" "võetud" "tema" "pensioni" "arvutamisel" "arvesse" "."


Input: "Selles" "mõttes" "„" "jätkuvad" "“" "selle" "karistuse" "tagajärjed" "tõesti" "ikka" "veel" "."


Input: "Seetõttu" "tuleb" "ennetähtaegse" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tulevikus" "tekkivate" "tagajärgede" "neutraliseerimisel" "neid" "kaotatud" "aastaid" "(" "kuidagi" ")" "arvesse" "võtta" "."


Input: "129" "." "Komisjon" "vaidleb" "sellele" "järeldusele" "vastu" "."


Input: "Ta" "on" "seisukohal" "," "et" "tagajärjed" "," "millest" "tulenevalt" "pensioniõigused" "ennetähtaegse" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tõttu" "ei" "suurene" "," "võib" "säilitada" "."


Input: "130" "." "Tunnistan" "," "et" "minu" "meelest" "ei" "ole" "võimalik" "ühitada" "komisjoni" "sellekohaseid" "põhjendusi" "tema" "seisukohaga" "," "et" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamine" "," "nagu" "see" "on" "distsiplinaarotsusega" "määratud" "," "kujutab" "endast" "„" "tulevikus" "tekkivaid" "tagajärgi" "“" "eespool" "viidatud" "tähenduses" "."


Input: "Mõlemad" "karistused" "–" "pensionile" "saatmine" "ja" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamine" "–" "määrati" "ühe" "ja" "sama" "faktiliste" "asjaolude" "kogumi" "põhjal" "ühe" "ja" "sama" "distsiplinaarotsusega" "."


Input: "Mõlemal" "juhul" "seisneb" "põhimõtteline" "küsimus" "selles" "," "millised" "olnuksid" "selle" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "tagajärjed" "," "kui" "see" "oleks" "tehtud" "kooskõlas" "direktiiviga" "2000" "/" "78" "."


Input: "131" "." "Kui" "nõustuda" "sellega" "," "kuidas" "komisjon" "eri" "tagajärgi" "eristab" "," "tähendaks" "see" "," "et" "sisuliselt" "oleks" "saanud" "kassaatori" "tema" "tööst" "ilma" "jätta" "ja" "ta" "ei" "oleks" "saanud" "seda" "vaidlustada" "."


Input: "Erinevalt" "pensionile" "saatmisest" "oleks" "kõnealune" "õigussuhe" "otsese" "töölt" "vallandamise" "korral" "lõppenud" "üldse" "ilma" "mingite" "pensionimakseteta" "."


Input: "132" "." "Seda" "arvestades" "–" "kui" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "järeldab" "," "et" "diskrimineeriva" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "tagajärgi" "ei" "saa" "säilitada" "," "ja" "kasutab" "„" "mis" "oleks" "," "kui" "“" "-" "lähenemisviisi" "–" "tuleks" "selles" "lähenemisviisis" "kaaluda" "alternatiivset" "stsenaariumi" "," "milles" "kassaator" "ei" "jää" "pensionile" "," "ning" "samuti" "stsenaariumi" "," "mille" "korral" "kassaatori" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamist" "(" "täielikult" ")" "ei" "rakendata" "."


Input: "133" "." "Mõistagi" "tekiks" "niisuguse" "lahenduse" "korral" "rida" "uusi" "keerukaid" "küsimusi" "."


Input: "Kas" "selleks" "et" "neutraliseerida" "1976" "." "aastal" "pensionile" "saatmisest" "„" "tulevikus" "tekkinud" "tagajärjed" "“" "," "tuleb" "eeldada" "," "et" "kassaator" "töötas" "kõik" "vahepealsed" "aastad" "alates" "1976" "." "aastast" "või" "kõik" "aastad" "alates" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "lõppemisest" "?"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "Kas" "võimalik" "vastav" "pensionitõus" "tuleb" "tasaarvestada" "kassaatori" "teiste" "töise" "tulu" "allikatega" "nendel" "aastatel" "?" "(" "57" ")" "Kas" "võimalik" "vastav" "pensionitõus" "tuleb" "tasaarvestada" "politseiteenistusest" "saadud" "pensionituluga" "," "mille" "kassaator" "on" "alates" "pensionile" "saatmisest" "juba" "kätte" "saanud" "(" "ja" "mida" "ta" "ei" "oleks" "kätte" "saanud" "," "kui" "ta" "oleks" "töötamist" "jätkanud" ")" "?" "(" "58" ")"


Input: "134" "." "Lõpuks" "," "mis" "puudutab" "konkreetselt" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamist" "," "on" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "teises" "küsimuses" "kaudselt" "eeldatud" "," "et" "see" "vähendamine" "on" "vaid" "kõnealuse" "otsuse" "diskrimineerivuse" "tagajärg" "."


Input: "135" "." "Ent" "„" "mis" "oleks" "," "kui" "?" "“" "peakski" "siis" "tähendama" "„" "mis" "oleks" "," "kui" "?" "“" "."


Input: "Seega" "tuleb" "arvestada" "võimalusega" "," "et" "isegi" "kui" "kassaatorit" "ei" "oleks" "kriminaalkorras" "süüdi" "mõistetud" "," "oleks" "teda" "samadel" "faktilistel" "asjaoludel" "ikkagi" "distsiplinaarkorras" "karistatud" "(" "59" ")" "ja" "kassaatori" "pensioni" "oleks" "ikkagi" "vähendatud" "," "kuid" "vähem" "kui" "25%" "võrra" "."


Input: "Just" "nii" "on" "sellele" "lähenenud" "komisjon" "oma" "kirjalikes" "seisukohtades" "."


Input: "Seega" "," "kui" "kassaatori" "pensioni" "oleks" "ka" "ilma" "diskrimineerimiseta" "vähendatud" "," "kuid" "näiteks" "ainult" "5" "või" "10%" "võrra" "," "tuleks" "selle" "5" "või" "10%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "tagajärjed" "säilitada" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "136" "." "Seega" "," "kui" "nõustuda" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "osas" "„" "mis" "oleks" "," "kui" "“" "-" "lähenemisviisiga" "," "olen" "komisjoniga" "nõus" "," "et" "see" "fiktsioon" "tuleb" "arendada" "loogilise" "lõpplahenduseni" "."


Input: "Jällegi" "peaks" "(" "tõepoolest" "üsna" "keeruka" ")" "küsimuse" "," "kuidas" "täpselt" "oleks" "distsiplinaarotsus" "olnud" "teistsugune" "," "kui" "see" "oleks" "tehtud" "ilma" "diskrimineerimata" "," "lahendama" "liikmesriigi" "kohus" "."


Input: "2" "." "Kolmas" "küsimus"


Input: "137" "." "Oma" "kolmandas" "küsimuses" "soovib" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "teada" "," "kas" "vastus" "teisele" "küsimusele" "oleneb" "sellest" "," "kas" "isik" "otsis" "enne" "pensioniea" "saabumist" "aktiivselt" "tööd" "föderaalses" "avalikus" "teenistuses" "."


Input: "138" "." "Pean" "tunnistama" "," "et" "põhikohtuasja" "faktilisi" "asjaolusid" "silmas" "pidades" "on" "niisuguse" "küsimuse" "asjakohasus" "minu" "jaoks" "mõistatus" "."


Input: "Ent" "kuna" "kõne" "all" "juba" "on" "„" "mis" "oleks" "," "kui" "“" "-" "stsenaariumid" "," "on" "üsna" "keeruline" "väita" "," "et" "see" "küsimus" "on" "hüpoteetiline" "."


Input: "139" "." "Juhtumi" "faktilised" "asjaolud" "ei" "anna" "selgust" "küsimuses" "," "kas" "kassaator" "tegelikult" "otsis" "(" "uut" ")" "tööd" "föderaalses" "avalikus" "teenistuses" "."


Input: "Vahest" "on" "mõistlik" "eeldada" "," "et" "kui" "isik" "on" "niisugustel" "asjaoludel" "nagu" "põhikohtuasjas" "sellest" "teenistusest" "vallandatud" "," "oleksid" "katsed" "uuesti" "samasse" "teenistusse" "tööle" "asuda" "üpris" "asjatud" "(" "kui" "üldse" "õiguslikult" "võimalikud" ")" "."


Input: "Kui" "see" "on" "tõepoolest" "nii" "ja" "kassaator" "ei" "otsinud" "edaspidi" "uut" "tööd" "föderaalses" "avalikus" "teenistuses" "," "siis" "milliseid" "järeldusi" "saab" "sellest" "teha" "?"


Input: "Kas" "kassaatorile" "saab" "ette" "heita" "," "et" "ta" "seda" "ei" "teinud" "?"


Input: "Kas" "see" "võib" "asetada" "ta" "ebasoodsamasse" "olukorda" "?"


Input: "140" "." "Siiski" "," "nagu" "on" "märgitud" "eespool" "punktis" "133" "," "kui" "see" "peaks" "oluline" "olema" "," "tekib" "sellest" "niivõrd" "," "kui" "ennetähtaegse" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tagajärjed" "tuleb" "neutraliseerida" "," "rida" "küsimusi" "," "kuidas" "käsitleda" "vahepealset" "perioodi" "."


Input: "Alternatiivse" "süžee" "arendamisel" "tuleks" "minu" "arvates" "jätta" "liikmesriigi" "kohtu" "otsustada" "," "milliseid" "konkreetseid" "üksikasju" "tuleb" "arvesse" "võtta" "tasakaalu" "leidmisel" "kahe" "võimaluse" "vahel" ":" "kas" "jätta" "need" "vahepealsed" "aastad" "üldse" "arvesse" "võtmata" "või" "võtta" "need" "täielikult" "arvesse" "," "nagu" "oleks" "kassaator" "sel" "ajal" "avalikus" "sektoris" "töötanud" "."


Input: "C" "." "Neljas" "ja" "viies" "küsimus"


Input: "141" "." "Eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "esimesele" "küsimusele" "pakutud" "vastust" "arvestades" "ei" "ole" "ka" "neljandale" "ega" "viiendale" "küsimusele" "vaja" "vastata" "."


Input: "Juhuks" "," "kui" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "peaks" "otsustama" "teisiti" "," "lisan" "mõned" "soovitused" "."


Input: "142" "." "Oma" "neljandas" "ja" "viiendas" "küsimuses" "soovib" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohus" "teada" "," "millisest" "hetkest" "peaks" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "(" "osaline" ")" "tühistamine" "jõustuma" "."


Input: "Need" "küsimused" "piirduvad" "ajahetkega" "," "millest" "alates" "peavad" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "tagajärjed" "neutraliseeritud" "olema" "."


Input: "Need" "ei" "hõlma" "ennetähtaegse" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tagajärgi" "."


Input: "Ent" "nagu" "eespool" "punktis" "133" "märgitud" "," "olen" "seisukohal" "," "et" "kui" "läheneda" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "tulevikus" "tekkivatele" "tagajärgedele" "ühtviisi" "ja" "pensionile" "saatmise" "tulevikus" "tekkivatele" "tagajärgedele" "teistviisi" "," "tekib" "sellest" "probleeme" "järjepidevusega" "."


Input: "143" "." "Minu" "arvates" "tuleneb" "vastus" "sellele" "küsimusele" "kohtupraktikast" "," "mille" "olen" "kokku" "võtnud" "käesoleva" "ettepaneku" "punktis" "44" "ja" "sellele" "järgnevates" "punktides" "."


Input: "Loodetavasti" "kehtib" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "kohaldamise" "suhtes" "tagasiulatuva" "jõu" "puudumise" "põhimõte" "," "olenemata" "eespool" "kirjeldatud" "potentsiaalselt" "kaugeleulatuvast" "lähenemisviisist" "seoses" "tulevikus" "tekkivate" "tagajärgede" "kõrvaldamisega" "."


Input: "Seetõttu" "," "olgu" "vastus" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "esimesele" "küsimusele" "milline" "tahes" "," "saab" "selle" "põhjal" "igal" "juhul" "argumenteerida" "," "et" "pensioni" "25%" "võrra" "vähendamise" "tagajärjed" "tuleb" "neutraliseerida" "alates" "direktiivi" "ülevõtmise" "tähtaja" "lõpust" "," "mitte" "varasemast" "ajast" "."


Input: "D" "." "Sooline" "diskrimineerimine"


Input: "1" "." "Eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "küsimuste" "ulatus"


Input: "144" "." "Lõpuks" "väitis" "kassaator" "oma" "kirjalikes" "seisukohtades" "," "et" "distsiplinaarotsusega" "määratud" "karistus" "kujutab" "endast" "(" "ka" ")" "soolist" "diskrimineerimist" "," "mis" "on" "vastuolus" "ELTL" "artikliga" "157" "(" "varem" "EMÜ" "artikkel" "119" "ja" "siis" "EÜ" "artikkel" "141" ")" "."


Input: "Kassaatori" "sõnul" "saab" "sellele" "esimest" "korda" "1979" "." "aastal" "jõustunud" "sättele" "tuginedes" "välistada" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "tulevikus" "tekkivad" "tagajärjed" "viisil" "," "mis" "sarnaneb" "sellega" "," "millele" "liikmesriigi" "kohus" "on" "oma" "esimeses" "küsimuses" "seoses" "direktiiviga" "2000" "/" "78" "osutanud" "."


Input: "See" "juhtuks" "siiski" "alates" "palju" "varasemast" "kuupäevast" "."


Input: "145" "." "Märgiksin" "selle" "kohta" "järgmist" "."


Input: "146" "." "Liikmesriigi" "kohus" "ei" "ole" "ELTL" "artiklile" "157" "(" "ega" "sellele" "eelnenud" "sätetele" ")" "viidanud" "."


Input: "Kassaator" "on" "tõepoolest" "ainus" "menetlusosaline" "," "kes" "on" "selle" "küsimuse" "oma" "kirjalikes" "seisukohtades" "tõstatanud" "."


Input: "Võib" "väita" "," "et" "ELTL" "artikli" "157" "võimaliku" "kohaldamise" "käsitlemine" "oleks" "liikmesriigi" "kohtule" "abiks" "."


Input: "Minu" "arvates" "aga" "ei" "peaks" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "seda" "tegema" "," "eeskätt" "järgmistel" "põhjustel" "."


Input: "147" "." "Esiteks" "ei" "ole" "eelotsusetaotluse" "esitanud" "kohtu" "küsimustes" "ega" "eelotsusetaotluses" "üldisemalt" "üldse" "sellele" "sättele" "viidatud" "."


Input: "Kui" "liikmesriigi" "kohus" "oleks" "seda" "asjakohaseks" "pidanud" "," "oleks" "ta" "minu" "arvates" "pidanud" "seda" "vähemalt" "mainima" "."


Input: "Sellisel" "väljajätmisel" "võib" "olla" "mitmeid" "põhjusi" "ja" "oleks" "vale" "eeldada" "," "et" "viite" "puudumine" "on" "„" "kahe" "silma" "vahele" "jätmine" "“" "."


Input: "Küsimus" "ei" "ole" "selles" "," "kas" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "peaks" "osutama" "kahe" "silma" "vahele" "jääda" "võinud" "obskuurse" "tehnilise" "õigusnormi" "üksikasjadele" "ja" "olulisusele" "."


Input: "ELTL" "artikkel" "157" "on" "oluline" "aluslepingu" "säte" "."


Input: "Kuna" "ELTL" "artiklit" "157" "käsitlevad" "argumendid" "on" "kassaatori" "kirjalikes" "märkustes" "õigupoolest" "kesksel" "kohal" "," "on" "samuti" "mõeldav" "," "et" "kassaator" "tegi" "liikmesriigi" "kohtule" "ettepaneku" "esitada" "Euroopa" "Kohtule" "selle" "sätte" "kohta" "küsimusi" "," "ent" "see" "ettepanek" "lükati" "tagasi" "."


Input: "148" "." "Teiseks" "on" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "kodukorra" "artiklis" "94" "nõutud" "," "et" "eelotsusetaotlus" "sisaldaks" "muu" "hulgas" "ülevaadet" "asjasse" "puutuvatest" "faktilistest" "asjaoludest" "ja" "riigisisestest" "õigusnormidest" "ning" "sellest" "," "millistel" "põhjustel" "esitas" "liikmesriigi" "kohus" "need" "konkreetsed" "küsimused" "."


Input: "Käesolevas" "asjas" "ei" "ole" "liikmesriigi" "kohus" "eelotsusetaotluses" "ELTL" "artiklit" "157" "(" "ega" "sellele" "eelnenud" "sätteid" ")" "üldse" "maininud" "ning" "selle" "sättega" "seoses" "ei" "ole" "ta" "viidanud" "potentsiaalselt" "olulistele" "faktilistele" "asjaoludele" "ega" "riigisisestele" "õigusnormidele" "."


Input: "Arvan" "," "et" "sellistel" "asjaoludel" "oleks" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "kodukorra" "artiklit" "94" "käsitleva" "kohtupraktikaga" "(" "60" ")" "vastuolus" "neid" "väljajätmisi" "eirata" "ja" "anda" "ühe" "menetlusosalise" "nõudmisel" "proaktiivselt" "suuniseid" "küsimuses" "," "mida" "ei" "ole" "küsitud" "."


Input: "149" "." "Juhuks" "," "kui" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "siiski" "otsustab" "kassaatori" "poolt" "seoses" "ELTL" "artikliga" "157" "esitatud" "argumente" "käsitleda" "," "sõnastan" "järgnevas" "jaos" "lühidalt" "mõned" "tähelepanekud" "."


Input: "2" "." "ELTL" "artikkel" "157"


Input: "150" "." "Selgitasin" "esimesele" "küsimusele" "pakutud" "vastuses" "," "miks" "direktiiv" "2000" "/" "78" "ei" "takista" "distsiplinaarotsuse" "tagajärgede" "säilitamist" "."


Input: "See" "otsus" "oli" "väljaspool" "direktiivi" "ajalist" "kohaldamisala" "."


Input: "Direktiivi" "ei" "saa" "kasutada" "selle" "otsuse" "uuesti" "menetlusse" "võtmiseks" "," "et" "mõningad" "selle" "tagajärjed" "neutraliseerida" "."


Input: "Need" "argumendid" "kehtivad" "mutatis" "mutandis" "ka" "ELTL" "artikli" "157" "kohta" "."


Input: "151" "." "Kui" "Euroopa" "Kohus" "jõuab" "teistsugusele" "järeldusele" "," "on" "liikmesriigi" "kohtu" "ülesanne" "teha" "kindlaks" "niisuguse" "diskrimineerimise" "võimalik" "esinemine" "."


Input: "Peamine" "argument" "on" "minu" "arusaama" "järgi" "siiski" "see" "," "et" "meessoost" "homoseksuaale" "koheldi" "ebasoodsamalt" "kui" "naissoost" "homoseksuaale" "." "(" "61" ")" "Kassaator" "osutas" "," "et" "naissoost" "politseiametnikule" "," "kes" "oleks" "asunud" "homoseksuaalsesse" "tegevusse" "üle" "14aastase" "alaealisega" "," "ei" "oleks" "distsiplinaarkaristust" "määratud" "(" "või" "oleks" "määratud" "igal" "juhul" "leebem" "distsiplinaarkaristus" ")" "," "erinevalt" "samalaadsesse" "tegevusse" "asunud" "meessoost" "homoseksuaalsest" "politseiametnikust" "."


Input: "152" "." "Niivõrd" "kui" "selline" "väide" "faktiliselt" "paika" "peab" "(" "pidades" "silmas" "Austria" "politsei" "distsiplinaarpraktikat" "1970" "." "aastatel" ")" "," "mille" "kindlakstegemine" "on" "liikmesriigi" "kohtu" "ülesanne" "," "keelab" "ELTL" "artikkel" "157" "soolise" "diskrimineerimise" "seoses" "„" "tasuga" "“" "."


Input: "Väljakujunenud" "kohtupraktika" "kohaselt" "ei" "hõlma" "„" "tasu" "“" "selles" "tähenduses" "seadusega" "ette" "nähtud" "pensioniskeemidest" "tehtavaid" "väljamakseid" "," "mis" "liigitatakse" "hoopis" "sotsiaalkindlustushüvitisteks" "." "(" "62" ")" "Kohtuistungil" "märkis" "Austria" "valitsus" "," "et" "käesoleval" "juhul" "käsitletav" "pensioniskeem" "on" "seadusega" "ette" "nähtud" "."


Input: "Kas" "see" "tõepoolest" "(" "Euroopa" "Kohtu" "praktikale" "omistatud" "tähenduses" "(" "63" ")" ")" "nii" "on" "," "on" "jällegi" "liikmesriigi" "kohtu" "kontrollida" "."


Input: "Austria" "valitsuse" "sellekohase" "väite" "põhjal" "aga" "ei" "kuulu" "sedalaadi" "maksed" "põhimõtteliselt" "ELTL" "artikli" "157" "kohaldamisalasse" "," "mistõttu" "ei" "ole" "see" "säte" "käesolevas" "asjas" "kohaldatav" "."


Input: "153" "." "Kui" "see" "siiski" "nii" "ei" "ole" "," "tuleks" "kaaluda" "ELTL" "artikli" "157" "(" "ja" "sellele" "eelnenud" "sätete" ")" "ajalist" "kohaldamist" "."


Input: "Viitan" "sellega" "seoses" "neljandat" "ja" "viiendat" "küsimust" "käsitledes" "sõnastatud" "tähelepanekutele" "," "mis" "kehtivad" "mutatis" "mutandis" "."


Input: "Pealegi" "võib" "kohtuotsuste" "Barber" "(" "64" ")" "ja" "Ten" "Oever" "(" "65" ")" "kohaselt" "„" "tugineda" "EMÜ" "asutamislepingu" "artikli" "119" "vahetule" "õigusmõjule" "selleks" "," "et" "nõuda" "võrdset" "kohtlemist" "tööandjapensioni" "küsimuses" "üksnes" "seoses" "hüvitistega" "," "mida" "makstakse" "17" "." "maile" "1990" "[" "s.o" "kohtuotsuse" "Barner" "kuupäevale" "]" "järgnevate" "töötamisperioodide" "eest" "," "välja" "arvatud" "töötajate" "või" "nende" "nimel" "nõude" "esitajate" "puhul" "," "kes" "on" "enne" "seda" "kuupäeva" "alustanud" "kohtumenetlust" "või" "esitanud" "võrdväärse" "nõude" "sellekohase" "riigisisese" "õiguse" "alusel" "“" "." "(" "66" ")"

"O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "154" "." "Eelotsusetaotluses" "kirjeldatud" "faktilistest" "asjaoludest" "aga" "nähtub" "," "et" "ükski" "asjasse" "puutuv" "töötamisperiood" "ei" "ole" "järgnenud" "17" "." "maile" "1990" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O"


Input: "V" "." "Ettepanek"


Input: "155" "." "Teen" "Euroopa" "Kohtule" "ettepaneku" "vastata" "Verwaltungsgerichtshofi" "(" "Austria" "kõrgeim" "halduskohus" ")" "esimesele" "küsimusele" "järgmiselt" ":"


Input: "Nõukogu" "27" "." "novembri" "2000" "." "aasta" "direktiivi" "2000" "/" "78" "/" "EÜ" "," "millega" "kehtestatakse" "üldine" "raamistik" "võrdseks" "kohtlemiseks" "töö" "saamisel" "ja" "kutsealale" "pääsemisel" "," "artikliga" "2" "ei" "ole" "vastuolus" "olukord" "," "kus" "ametnike" "distsiplinaarvastutust" "käsitlevate" "õigusnormide" "alusel" "tehtud" "haldusotsus" "(" "distsiplinaarotsus" ")" "," "mis" "on" "liikmesriigi" "õiguse" "alusel" "muutunud" "lõplikuks" "ja" "millega" "ametnik" "saadeti" "pensionile" "koos" "pensioni" "vähendamisega" "," "säilitab" "oma" "õigust" "kujundava" "toime" "," "kui"


Input: "–" "haldusotsuse" "tegemise" "ajal" "ei" "olnud" "liidu" "õiguse" "asjaomased" "sätted" "," "eelkõige" "direktiiv" "2000" "/" "78" "veel" "selle" "otsuse" "suhtes" "kohaldatavad" "," "kuid"


Input: "–" "samalaadne" "(" "mõeldav" ")" "otsus" "oleks" "direktiiviga" "2000" "/" "78" "vastuolus" "juhul" "," "kui" "see" "tehtaks" "direktiivi" "ajalises" "kohaldamisalas" "."


Input: "1" "Algkeel" ":" "inglise" "."


Input: "2" "Nõukogu" "27" "." "novembri" "2000" "." "aasta" "direktiiv" "," "millega" "kehtestatakse" "üldine" "raamistik" "võrdseks" "kohtlemiseks" "töö" "saamisel" "ja" "kutsealale" "pääsemisel" "(" "EÜT" "2000" "," "L" "303" "," "lk" "16" ";" "ELT" "eriväljaanne" "05" "/" "04" "," "lk" "79" ")" "."

"O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "3" "Verfassungsgerichtshofi" "(" "konstitutsioonikohus" "," "Austria" ")" "21" "." "juuni" "2002" "." "aasta" "otsus" "G" "6" "/" "02" "," "ECLI" ":" "AT" ":" "VFGH" ":" "2002" ":" "G6.2002" "."

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "O" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "B-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O"


Input: "4" "EIK" "9" "." "jaanuari" "2003" "." "aasta" "otsus" "L" "." "ja" "V" "." "vs" "."

"O" "O" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "O" "O" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "O" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "B-ADDRESS" "B-ADDRESS" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "O" "O" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "O" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O"

"O" "O" "B-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "B-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O"


Input: "Austria" "(" "CE" ":" "ECHR" ":" "2003" ":" "0109JUD003939298" ")" ";" "vt" "samuti" "EIK" "9" "." "jaanuari" "2003" "." "aasta" "otsus" "S" "." "L" "." "vs" "."

"I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O"

"B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"I-TIME" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "O" "O" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "O" "O"

"B-TIME" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "O" "O" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "O" "O"

"B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O"


Input: "Austria" "(" "CE" ":" "ECHR" ":" "2003" ":" "0109JUD004533099" ")" "ja" "21" "." "oktoobri" "2004" "." "aasta" "otsus" "Woditschka" "ja" "Wilfling" "vs" "."

"I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "I-ADDRESS" "O" "O"

"B-TIME" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "B-TIME" "O" "O" "B-TIME" "O" "B-TIME" "O" "O"

"I-TIME" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "I-TIME" "O" "O" "I-TIME" "O" "I-TIME" "O" "O"

"I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "I-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "B-AMOUNT" "O" "O"

"I-PERSON" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "I-PERSON" "O" "O" "I-PERSON" "O" "I-PERSON" "O" "O"

"I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "I-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "B-ORGANISATION" "O" "O"

"B-ADDRESS" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "O" "B-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "I-DATE" "O" "O" "B-PERSON" "O" "B-PERSON" "O" "O"